Podbit · The Diary Of A CEO with Steven Bartlett
Danny Meyer spent millions switching Shake Shack from crinkle-cut to fresh-cut fries to please a handful of New York food critics. It was a disaster. The lesson: know who the business is for, and forgive the voices that aren't in that group.
Where this was said
At 34:56 · chapter starts 33:17
The Shake Shack story is one of the episode's richest case studies. Danny Meyer, whose status was tied to New York's finest restaurants, spent millions switching from crinkle-cut to fresh-cut fries after elite food critics called the originals inauthentic. The results were catastrophic: fresh-cut fries are living things that vary by season, the staff hated making them, the internet erupted, and the only people pleased were the critics whose opinion had driven the change. [1] — Seth Godin "Danny Meyer spent millions switching Shake Shack from crinkle-cut to fresh-cut fries to please a handful of New York food critics. It was a…" 34:56 Meyer eventually asked the right question — do these fries exist to help a non-customer feel good about Danny Meyer, or to further the story of what it means to come to Shake Shack? — and switched back. Profits and productivity rose. Bartlett connects this to Amazon's empty chair practice, placing a seat for the customer in every meeting; Godin notes approvingly while flagging that Amazon has recently drifted by prioritising ad revenue over customer experience.
PropGPT launched with 20 downloads a day and strong influencer marketing but hit a ceiling at $1,000–$2,000 MRR. High download numbers masked a critical flaw: almost nobody stuck around after the free trial ended.
Eyal and Yali made a bold bet: stop all marketing, go back into the cave, and rebuild PropGPT from scratch. Four months of pure engineering and design work with zero revenue growth — and it paid off massively.
After rebuilding, PropGPT relaunched at $1,700 MRR. Within 2.5 months, it peaked at $40K MRR and 2,000 downloads in a single day. The product hadn't changed its audience — it had changed how well it served them.
Users didn't want a sports betting analytics tool — they wanted to be told the answer. Eyal realized their app was making users do the work when they just wanted the result, and that single insight drove the entire rebuild.
Step 1: know exactly who you're building for. Step 2: worship your data. Step 3: obsess over in-app analytics to find drop-off points. Step 4: scale with influencer marketing only after the product converts. In that order.
A 45% download-to-trial rate sounds great — until you see 13% trial-to-paid. That gap isn't a marketing problem. It's a product problem. Eyal breaks down how to read these signals before they kill your business.
Their 70th influencer video hit 600,000 views and single-handedly pushed PropGPT's ARR from $8,000 to $38,000 in three days. Influencer marketing has a lottery-like upside — but only if the product can hold the users it acquires.
Most founders struggle with distribution. Eyal and Yali had it nailed from day one — and still failed. Their story proves the rarer, less-discussed truth: a great go-to-market strategy is worthless if the product can't retain users.
Get a co-founder who has your back. Be scientifically honest about whether your idea has real demand. Once you convince yourself, it becomes an order of magnitude easier to convince investors and team members to join you.
We use essential and analytics cookies to run Vuci. To understand how the site is used: Privacy Policy.
Install Vuci on your phone
Add it to your home screen for a faster, app-like experience.
Install Vuci on your phone
Tap the Share button, then “Add to Home Screen”.
A new version is available
Reload to get the latest Vuci.