Podbit · The Megyn Kelly Show
Nancy Guthrie has been missing since February 1st. By July, the FBI is actively contradicting itself on whether the ransom notes are authentic — Reuters says none are legitimate, Fox News says not so fast. The case has been mismanaged from the start, both publicly and investigatively.
Before the hearing, the public was promised Tyler's parents turned him in, a leftist political motive over LGBTQ rights, fingerprints on the gun, and footage of the actual shooting. What was actually presented in court: blurry, unidentifiable figures on a staircase, a car with a different exhaust system, and a witness who said he 'likes to wear jeans.' The gap between the promise and the delivery is staggering.
Lance Twiggs — the prosecution's key witness, granted immunity, and Tyler Robinson's former roommate and boyfriend — had DNA on the gun, the towel, and the Dremel used to carve the cartridges. His alibi? He slept until 1PM, 37 minutes after the shooting. He was immediately granted immunity and not subject to cross-examination. Owens argues he is the most likely federal asset who framed Robinson.
The ATF's forensic biologist Caitlin Oliver testified that calling Tyler Robinson the 'major DNA contributor' does not mean what the media said it means. It only refers to one mixed sample, not the whole gun. She confirmed that mixed samples — like a mug touched by multiple people — can make someone appear dominant in a tiny patch while the rest of the object tells a different story. She confirmed the 'DNA found on gun' headline was scientifically indefensible.
ATF forensic biologist Caitlin Oliver confirmed that Tyler Robinson's DNA on the rifle trigger was the most degraded of all samples — more degraded than Lance Twiggs' and Matt Robinson's. DNA degrades over time due to dust and humidity, not immediately after firing. If Tyler had just shot someone and tossed the gun, his DNA should be freshest. Owens calls this an absolute bombshell that the influencers worked overtime to bury.
ATF ballistics expert Samantha Carner testified the one usable bullet fragment — labeled 6A — had a diameter range of .286 to .301 inches. Tyler Robinson's .30-06 rifle fires bullets starting at .308 inches. The fragment is too small. Three of the seven fragments extracted from Charlie Kirk's body were never delivered to the ATF. One of the four that arrived was labeled as evidence, and even that doesn't match the alleged murder weapon.
Benny Johnson and other influencers told their audiences they witnessed clear 4K HD video of Tyler Robinson's face, his license plate, and his movements on the rooftop — the whole courthouse gasped. But Court TV accidentally captured the actual enhanced exhibit on camera. What's there: a single, undistinguishable pixel moving across the rooftop. Exhibit 12.1 is simply Exhibit 12.4 with red circles drawn on it and a digital zoom applied.
A debit card receipt places Tyler Robinson at a steakhouse in Panguitch, Utah at 9:47PM on September 10 — a three-hour drive from Utah Valley University. Yet text messages presented as evidence show him supposedly texting Lance Twiggs from near campus after 11PM, watching canines and guarding his rifle. The math doesn't work, and the messages have no timestamps.
Surveillance footage near the campus shows a Dodge Challenger with a dual exhaust system. Tyler Robinson's actual Dodge Challenger — towed from his driveway — has a single exhaust. Car enthusiasts flooded Owens with emails confirming this is a meaningful difference. A witness also reported the driver of the Challenger at 12:47AM was bald and accompanied by three others — not matching Tyler Robinson at all.
A victim who specifically tried to memorise her attacker's face — under peak emotional arousal — identified the wrong man with total certainty. Once she identified him in a lineup, his face overwrote her actual memory. DNA evidence decades later exonerated the convicted man.
We use essential and analytics cookies to run Vuci. To understand how the site is used: Privacy Policy.
Install Vuci on your phone
Add it to your home screen for a faster, app-like experience.
Install Vuci on your phone
Tap the Share button, then “Add to Home Screen”.
A new version is available
Reload to get the latest Vuci.