The Shawn Ryan Show

Podbit · The Shawn Ryan Show

#316 Brian Keating - The First Object Ever Found From Another Solar System

Explore episode Jun 25, 2026

Where this was said

The Near-Nobel Announcement and the Dust Contamination Failure

At 2:27:00 · chapter starts 2:19:10

On St. Patrick's Day 2014, the BICEP team held a press conference at Harvard — led by Avi Loeb — announcing what appeared to be the detection of primordial gravitational waves, the long-sought signature of cosmic inflation. The discovery made front pages worldwide. Keating, who had been removed from the team's leadership, harbored private doubts about the signal's robustness. Invoking Feynman's rule — 'the easiest person to fool is yourself' — he explains how the team missed a crucial contaminant: galactic dust from dead stars, the very material that makes up the meteorites he brought to the studio. That dust mimics the gravitational wave signature exactly. The claim was retracted in a deeply public and embarrassing correction. The story became the subject of his bestselling book *Losing the Nobel Prize*, and serves as the episode's most powerful illustration of scientific humility.

Similar podbits

Science
Microplastics: Were We Measuring Them Wrong?

“This Is The Culmination Of Everything I Know” - Dr Andrew … · Sep 14, 2026 Science

The widely shared claim that we have a credit card's worth of plastic in our brains may be a massive overestimate. Researchers used nitrile gloves to measure microplastics — and nitrile gloves shed microplastic particles onto the measuring device. A second paper found the original tool used was unreliable, and that we may have far less plastic than reported.

Science
The Door-Keeping Experiment: Our Irrational Addiction to Optionality

Finding Your Life Path, Solved · Sep 2, 2026 Science

In Dan Ariely's door experiment, participants sacrificed the highest-reward door — repeatedly — just to avoid seeing other doors disappear. Even when researchers trained them to use the best door, they kept wasting clicks to maintain options. This is the bias that runs our lives: we'll take a worse outcome to preserve the feeling of optionality.

Science
Dan Gilbert's Psychological Immune System: Why Your Brain Justifies Every Decision

Finding Your Life Path, Solved · Sep 2, 2026 Science

Dan Gilbert discovered that the brain has a 'psychological immune system' — it misremembers, reframes, and rationalizes to keep you satisfied with whatever you chose. The fear before commitment is all about potential regret. But after committing, your brain quietly starts justifying the choice — and the more irreversible the decision, the stronger the effect.

Science
The Placebo Effect Is Not Fake — It Just Belongs to the Story, Not the Drug

#403 ‒ Peptides: separating scientific promise from marketi… · Aug 10, 2026 Science

Peptides come loaded with a powerful narrative: regenerative, subcutaneous, targeted, cutting-edge. That narrative can genuinely move outcomes, especially for pain, energy, and recovery. The RCT's job is to quantify how much additional benefit comes from the molecule itself — above and beyond the compelling story surrounding it.