Kirk family attorney Jeff Nyman responded directly after Michael Burt's attack, telling the judge that the family has not seen the video, does not have access to state evidence, and that what Burt said was a complete distortion of reality. He kept it brief — unlike the judge who implored brevity and then spoke longer.
Tyler Robinson returned home after the shooting, and his roommate Lance Twiggs asked him point-blank if what he'd texted was real. Robinson said yes — and said he wished he hadn't done it. It is the most direct human confirmation of guilt in the entire case so far.
DNA from the rifle's stock, grip, and bolt was at least one trillion times more likely to have come from Tyler Robinson than from four unrelated individuals. This is the scientific spine of the state's case — and it's almost impossible to argue away.
The cartridges recovered from Robinson's rifle were engraved with 'Bella Ciao' — the famous anti-fascist anthem — along with 'A Fascist' and other political phrases. This evidence directly corroborates the politically motivated assassination enhancement charge.
Defense attorney Michael Burt used a procedural argument about evidence access to launch a personal attack on Erica Kirk, accusing her of holding press conferences and treating prosecutors as her private attorneys — none of which was true. Legal analyst Andrea Burkhart said even she was taken aback, calling it the kind of move good lawyers don't make.
Lance Twiggs told investigators Robinson left their apartment around 4 AM on September 10, claiming he had a 'long drive to work.' The drive from St. George to the UVU campus in Orem is about three hours and forty-five minutes — placing Robinson there precisely when campus surveillance footage shows the suspect arriving.
When shown the FBI's press release images of the campus suspect, Lance Twiggs said: 'That definitely looks like Tyler Robinson.' He identified the shoes, sunglasses, and clothing style as consistent with Robinson's typical appearance — a powerful lay identification from someone who knew him intimately.
Lance Twiggs testified that about a month before September 10, Robinson asked to borrow his Dremel tool to engrave bullets — telling him it was for a hunting trip. DNA from the same Dremel tool later matched Robinson, physically connecting him to the weapon preparation process.
Legal analyst Andrea Burkhart said that putting the probable cause affidavits in Robinson's and Bryan Kohberger's cases side by side, the amount of evidence against Robinson 'overwhelms' what was available against Kohberger at the same stage — yet the Robinson case has only a 50-50 public pre-judgment of guilt due to alternative theories.
The defense's approach is transparent: agonizing cross-examinations on boring technical details like bullet fragment analysis and David Engelhardt's letter, while rushing past the Twiggs video where Robinson confessed. The goal is to occupy jury headspace with confusion and minimize focus on the repeated confessions.
We use essential and analytics cookies to run Vuci. To understand how the site is used: Privacy Policy.
Install Vuci on your phone
Add it to your home screen for a faster, app-like experience.
Install Vuci on your phone
Tap the Share button, then “Add to Home Screen”.
A new version is available
Reload to get the latest Vuci.