Where this was said
Lorena Bobbitt's Trial & Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity
At 47:46 · chapter starts 46:10
At Lorena's trial, the same district attorney who had expressed implicit sympathy for her in the previous case now declared she 'belonged behind bars.' Lorena took the stand again, sobbing as she described being choked and raped, and told the male prosecutor directly: 'Maybe you don't understand because you're a man.' Her defense rested on a psychiatrist's argument that she was suffering from PTSD and 'struck at the instrument of her torture' in a moment of temporary insanity. The prosecution's own psychiatrist countered that the act was 'goal-oriented behavior' — she chose the weapon, chose the target, and acted deliberately, which is inconsistent with a truly impulsive break from reality. Ash and Alaina note they can see both arguments. The jury came down the middle: not guilty by reason of temporary insanity, with a recommendation that Lorena be committed for psychiatric evaluation. She was held at a mental health facility for more than a month before a judge accepted the hospital's report that she was no longer a danger and discharged her. [1] — Alaina Urquhart "Lorena acquitted — temporary insanity: On January 21, 1994, a jury found Lorena Bobbitt not guilty by reason of temporary insanity, recomme…" 48:32
At Lorena's trial for malicious wounding, her psychiatrist argued she struck at 'the instrument of her torture' while suffering from PTSD — a clean narrative of trauma response. The prosecution's psychiatrist countered that severing the penis was 'goal-oriented behavior,' not a truly impulsive act. The jury came down the middle: not guilty by reason of temporary insanity.
On January 21, 1994, a jury found Lorena Bobbitt not guilty by reason of temporary insanity, recommending she be committed to a psychiatric facility for evaluation.
After her acquittal, Lorena Bobbitt was sent to a mental health facility and underwent treatment and observation for more than a month before being discharged.
