Quote · Planet Money
We almost had a smartphone in the 90s. Why did it fail?
Where this was said
David Epstein's Theory: The Paradox of Abundance
At 14:45 · chapter starts 13:00
David Epstein, author of 'Inside the Box: How Constraints Make Us Better,' enters the episode with a provocative thesis. After studying successful creative organizations from Dr. Seuss to NASA to Pixar, Epstein found the same pattern: constraints drive creative success. General Magic is his most powerful negative example. The company was a spectacular failure precisely because it had too much — too much talent, too much time, too many resources. [1] — David Epstein "Journalist David Epstein spent years researching what makes creative people and organizations succeed. His counterintuitive finding: too mu…" 12:50 When Epstein got his hands on a Sony Magic Link, he found it was actually cool in a way, but completely incoherent, a device that did so many things it was impossible to know what it was for. The 200-page manual said it all. The hosts then introduce Epstein's three-lesson framework for understanding what went wrong.
The Sony Magic Link shipped with a 200-page manual, a sign that the product was too complex and incoherent for mainstream consumers.
General Magic invented an imaginary customer called 'Joe Sixpack' but never identified a real problem to solve for him. When Tony's mom sat in user testing, she couldn't figure out what the device was for — or why she'd ever need it.
General Magic's investors included Apple, AT&T, Sony, Motorola, Panasonic, and more. Their investor meetings required an antitrust lawyer to list forbidden topics. David Epstein argues they would have been better off staying very small for much longer — letting costs stay contained while setting boundaries.
