Crime Junkie

Quote · Crime Junkie

SERIAL KILLER: David Meirhofer

Explore episode Jun 1, 2026

Where this was said

The Family Heads Home — and the Kidnapper Calls Again

At 19:42 · chapter starts 14:40

As summer fades with no solid leads, the Jaegers — who have been living at the campground, sustained by kind locals — face the heartbreaking drive back to Michigan with one child missing. Marietta barely leaves the house; the phone has become her post. When she slips out for just 10 minutes to pick up her youngest son from catechism class, the kidnapper calls. Her 16-year-old son Dan presses record before answering. The two-minute recording — now lost, but preserved as a transcript — shows the kidnapper stringing the family along. He again references Susie's fingernails to prove himself, then tells Dan they'll be contacted again in 'a week, a month, maybe two months.' It is sustained, deliberate cruelty dressed up as ambiguity.

True Crime
The Recorded Call with the Kidnapper

SERIAL KILLER: David Meirhofer · Jun 1, 2026 True Crime

When Marietta stepped out for 10 minutes, the kidnapper called. Her 16-year-old son Dan hit record before answering. The two-minute call — now only a transcript — shows the killer stringing the family along with vague promises of contact 'in a month or two.'

Similar quotes