Quote · Fin vs History
Nazis Are No Match For Knobbly Knees | Monty vs Rommel (Part 1/4)
Where this was said
Get The Knees Out
At 5:48 · chapter starts 4:27
With the banter out of the way, Fin makes his first serious historiographical claim: the North African desert is the high point of 'Big Shorts' culture and the only part of WWII where Britain beats the Nazis without American assistance. Horatio notes this is probably why the rest of the world ignores it — the Americans arrive in 1943 and immediately make Monty's achievements seem irrelevant, while the Russians are busy doing the actual decisive fighting. The hosts agree the campaign is fascinating precisely because it's a gentleman's war: no Einsatzgruppen, no Holocaust, just a pure tactical ding-dong across a desert pitch. The football analogy arrives naturally — creating overloads, going in behind, beating the offside trap — and the debate settles on Cruyff versus Mourinho as the closest parallel to Monty's methodical style versus Rommel's free-wheeling genius.
The North African Desert campaign is the only part of World War II where Britain beats the enemy without American help. The Americans arrive in 1943 and immediately render everything Monty achieved largely irrelevant — which is probably why no one else talks about it.
The North African desert campaign is the only theatre of World War II where Britain defeats the enemy without American assistance.
The North African Desert campaign is the closest World War II ever gets to football: expansive play across a pitch, tactical overloads, breaking lines, beating the offside trap. Monty is the methodical manager; Rommel is the free-wheeling genius. The hosts debate whether it's Cruyff vs Mourinho or Arteta vs Luis Enrique.
There's a popular revisionist view that Rommel was 'not really a Nazi' — just a military professional whose heart wasn't in it. Fin disagrees. Rommel oversaw Hitler Youth training, commanded his personal escort battalion, and was a senior Nazi general. Measured against all of human history, he's still one of the most Nazi people who ever lived.
