The Journal.

Snapshot · The Journal.

Inside a Debate at OpenAI Over Mass Shootings

Explore episode Jun 26, 2026

Where this was said

The Summer Meeting: 10 Cases, 3 That Mattered Most

At 17:38 · chapter starts 15:08

Last summer, roughly a dozen OpenAI employees sat down specifically to ask a structural question: was the company's threshold for referring cases to law enforcement set at the right level? Should they lower the bar? On the table were about 10 cases of users who had discussed violence with ChatGPT. Three stood out. One involved a Tennessee teenager apparently planning a school shooting — that case had been referred to police. But the other two hadn't: a Texas high schooler with detailed, specific, and repeated violent fantasies played out with ChatGPT's full cooperation; and a user in Canada whose conversations about gun violence had disturbed multiple employees. The meeting was a genuine debate, with some employees arguing for more referrals and leadership pushing back on privacy grounds. The outcome: the policy stayed exactly as it was.

Similar snapshots