The Moth

Snapshot · The Moth

Cotton Candy and Revolutionary Rides: The Moth Radio Hour

Explore episode Jun 30, 2026

Where this was said

Nadia Bolz-Weber: The Pastor Who Founded a Church She'd Actually Want to Attend

At 10:30 · chapter starts 3:24

Nadia Bolz-Weber opens by acknowledging the awkwardness of being a Lutheran pastor who dislikes church — a feeling she earned from a rigid, joyless upbringing. Her solution: start from scratch. In 2008, she founded House for All Sinners and Saints, designing it to have 'very few rules, a whole lot of fun, and everyone gets to be themselves.' The congregation quickly became distinctive: a velvet painting of a crying Elvis greeted worshippers; bicycle blessings replaced blessing of the animals; a bar basement hosted 'Beer and Hymns' quarterly. Stuart, the congregation's unofficial minister of fabulousness and church drag queen, exemplified the spirit — his stewardship campaign t-shirts read 'This shit ain't free' on the front and 'So you better tithe, bitches' on the back. But the congregation was small, and denominational pressure meant every Sunday felt like 'throwing my own birthday party.' Summer attendance fell to 35, then lower — setting up the catastrophic Rally Day she had staked everything on.

Religion & Spirituality
Why Nadia Bolz-Weber Started a Church in a Bar Basement

Cotton Candy and Revolutionary Rides: The Moth Radio Hour · Jun 30, 2026 Religion & Spirituality

Nadia Bolz-Weber grew up in a strict conservative church with too many rules and no room to be herself. So she founded House for All Sinners and Saints in 2008, a congregation designed around minimal rules, maximum fun, and radical inclusion — complete with a velvet Elvis at the door and a minister of fabulousness.

Religion & Spirituality
The Rally Day Disaster

Cotton Candy and Revolutionary Rides: The Moth Radio Hour · Jun 30, 2026 Religion & Spirituality

Nadia Bolz-Weber hauled a cotton candy machine, cases of soda, and burgers for 80 people to Rally Day — and 26 people showed up. She snuck downstairs to pray away her fury before the service, confessing she hated the people who didn't come so much she couldn't appreciate the ones who did.

Similar snapshots

Religion & Spirituality
Average Mormon net worth $1.7 million

#2535 - Andrew Wilson · Aug 5, 2026

A stat surfaced on the show suggesting the average Mormon is worth $1.7 million, far above the average Catholic, attributed to Mormon nepotism and tithing practices.

Religion & Spirituality
Mormon Church worth ~$100 billion

#2535 - Andrew Wilson · Aug 5, 2026

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints reportedly holds around $100 billion in assets, making it the richest single church in the world.