Snapshot · The Ben Shapiro Show
The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 upholding birthright citizenship, with Kavanaugh refusing to join Thomas and Alito on the substantive constitutional point.
Where this was said
At 1:04:10 · chapter starts 54:55
Theo Wold, who worked on the Trump administration's birthright citizenship executive order, joins Michael Knowles and Ben Domenech to break down what went wrong at the Supreme Court. He explains that both Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett signaled skepticism at oral argument, and that Roberts' majority opinion is essentially an 'armchair historian's view' of the 14th Amendment rooted in Anglo common law — specifically the concept of subjecthood, not citizenship. [1] — Theo Wold "Chief Justice Roberts anchored his birthright citizenship ruling in 15th-century Anglo common law — and Theo Wold argues he missed everythi…" 56:10 Alito and Thomas both dissented correctly, Wold argues, noting that Roberts missed everything from the Declaration of Independence forward. The natural rights theorist Hadley Arkes pinpoints the flaw: Roberts defines citizenship as 'the right to have rights,' which would have struck the Framers as bizarre. Knowles adds the decisive historical counter: the United Kingdom — the very legal tradition Roberts invokes — abolished birthright citizenship in 1981, effective 1983, precisely because of mass migration. So if you're going to cite English common law, you should at least look at what the English actually did with it. [2] — Theo Wold "The executive order approach was always a gamble — and the Supreme Court called the bluff. Theo Wold explains that because the Court issued…" 1:06:00 Wold explains that the executive order approach, while legally interesting, failed to generate the political and legislative momentum needed and that most congressional remedies are now foreclosed by the constitutional ruling — meaning a fix will require a constitutional amendment. Ben Domenech, a longtime supporter of birthright citizenship who now has reservations given the scale of the Biden-era border crisis, says Roberts' opinion is 'crap' but that most Americans will simply shrug at the outcome.
Chief Justice Roberts anchored his birthright citizenship ruling in 15th-century Anglo common law — and Theo Wold argues he missed everything from the Declaration of Independence forward. The real kicker: Britain itself abolished birthright citizenship in 1981, making Roberts' appeal to English tradition incoherent.
Michael Knowles highlighted that the UK voted to end birthright citizenship in 1981, effective 1983, directly in response to mass migration pressures — a parallel the US Supreme Court ignored.
The executive order approach was always a gamble — and the Supreme Court called the bluff. Theo Wold explains that because the Court issued a constitutional ruling rather than a statutory one, most congressional options are now foreclosed. Fixing birthright citizenship will require a constitutional amendment.
A total of 8 states have filed lawsuits against social media platforms, including an ongoing case in Tennessee, using product liability and public nuisance theories to seek accountability.
France built 56 nuclear plants in the 1970s and now has the cheapest energy in Europe, making it independent of Russian or Middle Eastern energy geopolitics.
Estonia has a single tax form, a law preventing the government from asking citizens for the same information twice, and a flat rate of tax — enabling competitive taxation.
Portugal's Lisbon, once a city with a major heroin problem, legalised drugs and redirected enforcement spending into rehabilitation and housing, dramatically reducing crime.
The first Boland Amendment banning CIA and Defense Department funds for the Contras passed the House unanimously — yet the Reagan administration ignored it.
Over just two years, Saudi Arabia alone donated $32 million to the Contra rebels, giving loosely affiliated factions millions they had no way to spend on arms.
The National Endowment for the Preservation of Liberty raised $6.3 million for the Contras but only $3.3 million reached them — a shockingly low 52% program expense rate.
Richard Secord and Albert Hakim marked up their arms shipments to the Contras by as much as 300%, making enormous personal profits from the covert operation.
Lieutenant Colonel Oliver North, tapped to run the entire covert Contra support operation, had no prior experience in covert operations whatsoever — he was learning as he went.
We use essential and analytics cookies to run Vuci. To understand how the site is used: Privacy Policy.
Install Vuci on your phone
Add it to your home screen for a faster, app-like experience.
Install Vuci on your phone
Tap the Share button, then “Add to Home Screen”.
A new version is available
Reload to get the latest Vuci.