The Ben Shapiro Show

Snapshot · The Ben Shapiro Show

Ep. 2456 - LIVE: Ben Breaks Down SCOTUS on Birthright Citizenship

Explore episode Jun 30, 2026

Where this was said

Justice Alito's Dissent: Congress Should Fix This, Not the Court

At 51:20 · chapter starts 48:20

Alito's dissent follows a similar historical path to Thomas's but adds a sharp policy critique: the court is using a constitutionally mandated floor to duck responsibility for a problem that Congress should solve. Alito argues the 14th Amendment only requires citizenship for those who owe sole allegiance to the U.S. at birth — a narrower standard that would exclude children of illegal or temporarily present foreign nationals. He insists that Congress retains the power to go further and grant citizenship more broadly, including potentially amnestying Dreamers. But that is Congress's choice to make, not a constitutional mandate. Shapiro quotes Alito's memorable line that 'before saddling the nation with a medieval rule, we had better be certain the Constitution requires it,' and presents his rebuttal to Roberts's argument that leaving bad precedent in place is justified by the disruption of stripping citizenship from millions. Alito says bad law remains bad law regardless of the disruption its correction causes.

Similar snapshots