Good Hang with Amy Poehler

Snapshot · Good Hang with Amy Poehler

Sarah Sherman

Explore episode Jun 16, 2026
TV & Film
First SNL audition at age 22

Sarah Sherman · Jun 16, 2026

Sarah auditioned for SNL at 22 at Sharna Halpern's urging, bombed badly by doing what she thought the assignment was — characters and impressions — rather than being herself.

Where this was said

The First SNL Audition Bomb and the Spite Career

At 41:41 · chapter starts 41:30

Sharna Halpern set up Sarah's first SNL audition when Sarah was 22 and performing as Sarah Squirm. Sarah knew it was probably too soon but went anyway. She did what she thought the assignment was — characters and impressions — and it was obviously terrible, she says. She remembers her outfit in crystalline detail (her memories are always marked by clothes) but less vividly the actual set, which is telling. This follows her Northwestern rejection from the sketch group, which she describes as devastating. Both rejections are fuel: Sarah is explicitly motivated by spite, and getting a 'no' from peers or institutions tends to sharpen her creative ambition rather than deflate it.

TV & Film
Outside-In: Sarah Sherman's Six-Year Revelation

Sarah Sherman · Jun 16, 2026 TV & Film

Sarah Sherman admits she has spent six years at SNL building characters from the outside in — picking the wig before knowing the motivation. Watching castmate Ashley Padilla work from internal character truth made her realize her approach was making writing twice as hard. She's trying to flip it for season six.

Similar snapshots

TV & Film
Motor City — no dialogue silent film

Alan Ritchson · Jul 27, 2026

Motor City is a film with zero spoken dialogue, originally conceived by then-Warner Bros. president Greg Silverman so that global audiences could share the same experience without language barriers.

TV & Film
Motor City on Hollywood Blacklist since 2009

Alan Ritchson · Jul 27, 2026

The Motor City script appeared on Hollywood's prestigious Blacklist of best unproduced screenplays as early as 2009 and was greenlit nine times with different directors before finally being made.

TV & Film
Thor audition — 'he doesn't have the craft'

Alan Ritchson · Jul 27, 2026

Alan Ritchson's failed Thor audition was so poor the casting director broke protocol to call his team and say he didn't have the craft — a moment Ritchson describes as the career-defining crossroads that sent him to acting school.