Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Snapshot · Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Ep. 117 | Mysterious Missing Children Cold Cases

Explore episode Jul 1, 2026

Where this was said

The Suspect: George Washington

At 11:54 · chapter starts 11:00

Within the family's orbit, one person drew far more scrutiny than anyone else: Tracy's boyfriend George Washington, who was secretly married to another woman also named Diamond, had been confirmed by DNA testing as Diamond Bradley's biological father — a fact he denied — and had proposed the suspicious camping trip to Lake Shafer, Indiana the day before the girls vanished. On the morning of July 6, George made a run to Home Depot for bleach, contractor bags, and heavy-duty gloves, with four bags unaccounted for from the roll. He claimed the items were for home renovations and that he'd thrown the bags into a Washington Park lagoon — but they were never found. Neighbours reported watching him burn something in a 55-gallon drum at his garage before loading the barrel into his car and driving off; investigators found charring and the outline of a drum in his vehicle. Most damning, forensic testing found hair in his trunk: one strand matching Tionda and one matching Tracy. George explained it by claiming he'd hidden the girls in the trunk to avoid drive-in theatre cover charges. That night he drove to Gary, Indiana — about 45 minutes from Chicago — reportedly arriving visibly rattled at a woman's door, though the account was never confirmed.

True Crime
The Evidence Against George Washington

Ep. 117 | Mysterious Missing Children Cold Cases · Jul 1, 2026 True Crime

The day the Bradley girls vanished, George Washington bought bleach, contractor bags, and heavy-duty gloves. Neighbors watched him burn something in a 55-gallon drum and drive off with it. Investigators found hair in his trunk matching Tionda — yet no charges have ever been filed because the evidence is circumstantial.

True Crime
The Coached Note and the Missing Voicemail

Ep. 117 | Mysterious Missing Children Cold Cases · Jul 1, 2026 True Crime

The note attributed to 10-year-old Tionda was too grammatically polished for a child her age, and Tionda always called — she never wrote notes. A voicemail allegedly placing the girls with George was heard by family members and then vanished from the system. The evidence that could have cracked this case keeps disappearing.

Similar snapshots