Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Snapshot · Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Ep. 117 | Mysterious Missing Children Cold Cases

Explore episode Jul 1, 2026

Where this was said

The Search and the Cowboy Boots That Were Never Found

At 26:20 · chapter starts 24:10

Jessica Mitchell called 911 at 2:28 PM on July 10, 2015, reporting her 2-year-old son missing. While Mitchell's phone caught just enough reception at the campsite to make the call, Vernal Kunz drove down a dirt road to find a signal and alert police. Within 48 hours the response was enormous: crews on foot, ATVs, horseback, helicopters overhead, canine units, and divers in the reservoir and creek who went belly-down to manually tear apart log jams and brush piles. By day three the volunteer count exceeded 200 people, and Sheriff John Bennett was personally diving in the water. Grid searchers walked side by side close enough to hold hands, covering the campsite and surrounding terrain step by step. The Bonneville County Sheriff's Office and FBI joined the effort; DeOrr's photo went up on billboards across eastern Idaho. Investigators pursued leads including one placing the toddler at a California Motel 6, and anthropologists at Idaho State University examined multiple bone discoveries at the campsite — each time confirming only animal remains. One set was sent to the FBI's Quantico lab and came back the same. The oversized boots were a nagging forensic puzzle: if an animal grabbed DeOrr or someone snatched him quickly, loose boots should have fallen off. But not a single boot was ever found anywhere.

Similar snapshots