Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Snapshot · Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Ep. 114 | This Murder Case Took a Turn Nobody Expected | Moriah Wilson

Explore episode Jun 10, 2026

Where this was said

Flight: Stolen Passport, Fake Names, and a New Face in Costa Rica

At 1:01:28 · chapter starts 54:40

On May 13th, the day after police let her walk, Armstrong drove her Jeep to a South Austin CarMax and sold it for $12,200 cash — well below its $30,000+ market value. She flew to New York, connected with her sister Christine at a campground upstate, and then stole Christine's passport before boarding United Airlines flight 1222 from Newark to San José, Costa Rica on May 18th — what would have been Moriah Wilson's 26th birthday. In Costa Rica, she moved from San José to Jacó to Santa Teresa, a Pacific Coast surf village where drifters blended easily into the scenery. She checked into Don John's Lodge, ran reception, taught yoga classes, and cycled through three aliases — Beth Martin, Liz Martin, and Ari Martin. Then she disappeared for days and returned with a bandaged nose and swollen lips: she had paid $6,360 for a rhinoplasty, lip fillers, and a brow lift in San José under the name Allison Page. She even grew uncomfortable when her surgeon tried to take a pre-surgery photo.

True Crime
Plastic Surgery, Fake Passports, and a New Face: Armstrong's Flight to Costa Rica

Ep. 114 | This Murder Case Took a Turn Nobody Expected | Mo… · Jun 10, 2026 True Crime

Armstrong flew to Costa Rica on her sister's stolen passport, dyed her hair, cycled through three aliases, then paid $6,360 for a rhinoplasty and lip fillers to change her face. US Marshals eventually found her using a fake yoga instructor job posting on a Facebook community group.

True Crime
The Fake Job Ad That Caught a Murderer

Ep. 114 | This Murder Case Took a Turn Nobody Expected | Mo… · Jun 10, 2026 True Crime

After weeks of failed searches, US Marshals posted a bogus yoga instructor job ad on a Santa Teresa community Facebook group. Armstrong took the bait under the alias Ari Martin, suggested meeting at the hostel where she'd been staying, and was identified by Deputy Marshal Perez who leaned in close — her new nose was bandaged, but her eyes hadn't changed.

Similar snapshots