The Hidden Third

Snapshot · The Hidden Third

The World’s Best Bounty Hunter: How Michelle Gomez Finds People Who Vanish

Explore episode Jun 24, 2026

Where this was said

The Ryan Mullen Case: Catching a Federal Fugitive on His Bayou Yacht

At 44:20 · chapter starts 39:30

The Ryan Mullen case is what put Michelle on the map. A collection agency hired her to repossess a yacht from a man who had defrauded banks using fake checks and fabricated financial statements — and had left investigators at every level completely confused. When Michelle was already working the case, a U.S. Marshal named Chesby called to inform her that Mullen was also wanted by the federal government for stealing $2 million. She immediately knew the Marshal's tip about Mullen being in the Florida Keys was wrong — she'd already called Harbor Police and confirmed he wasn't there. Following her intelligence on his three-person support triangle — a central figure, a finance man, and movers — she tracked down his finance accomplice, saw a rosary on his rearview mirror, and used his Catholic faith and his dying daughter's illness to pressure him into cooperating. The accomplice stalled her for an hour and a half to give Mullen time to escape, but Michelle and journalist Randall Sullivan raced to a Louisiana plantation, found Mullen on the deck actively untying his yacht's ropes, and arrested him. She was in shorts and flip-flops. When he demanded to know who she was, she replied: 'I'm Michelle Gomez.' His parrot was carried off repeating 'Kill 'em all' and 'Where's Mullen?' to the growing crowd.

Similar snapshots