256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson

A husband secretly photographed his wife's belongings in pairs on a hidden camera — and a decade later, there's still no explanation.

Feb 19, 2026 1:38:39 Difficulty: Beginner Played

TL;DR

Morgan Absher teams up with comedian Taylor Tomlinson to react to a set of Reddit's most unresolved "suspicious behavior" posts. They tackle a husband's hidden camera full of photos of his wife's belongings, a fiancé who hid a secret room for 8 months, a guy who accidentally "kidnapped" his fiancée for a birthday surprise and called the cops, a husband who locked his 6-months-pregnant wife outside in the snow, and a wife who built a fake Facebook profile to surveil her husband's exes. The single most useful takeaway: gut feelings and good communication are everything.

#AITA Reddit #relationship red flags #hidden camera mystery #secret room #fake pregnancy proposal #therapy letter privacy #domestic control #gut instinct vs anxiety #jealousy and trust #Taylor Tomlinson Netflix #Two Hot Takes podcast #Reddit stories #suspicious behavior #hidden camera #fake pregnancy #Taylor Tomlinson #Two Hot Takes #gut instinct #therapy #controlling behavior #jealousy #mental health #comedy #AITA

Two Hot Takes host Morgan Absher is joined by comedian Taylor Tomlinson to react to Reddit's most suspicious and unresolved relationship stories, including a hidden camera, a secret room, a fake pregnancy proposal, a birthday kidnapping, and a wife who built a fake social media profile of her husband.

Chapter list
  • The third story delivers the episode's most satisfying plot twist. A 22-year-old woman describes how her 23-year-old fiancé — who'd found a pregnancy test in his parents' bathroom weeks earlier — grabbed a champagne glass out of her hand at a New Year's party, then publicly accused her of risking 'the baby.' He proposed because he was 'stepping up.' She is absolutely not pregnant. The update confirms what Taylor Tomlinson clocked immediately: it was his mother's test. His mom was pregnant in her 40s and hadn't told anyone. The chaos unfolds in real time — the boyfriend genuinely thought he was doing the right thing, the girlfriend is left questioning whether she was only proposed to because he thought she was pregnant, and the mother's confession ends the standoff. The story becomes a launching pad for a deeply personal detour: Taylor reveals she spent years in therapy convinced a long-term boyfriend wasn't cheating on her — working through her 'paranoia' — only for him to admit years later he'd been seeing sex workers the whole time. Her first feeling was relief, not anger. She and Morgan then unpack the hard, important question: what's the difference between gut instinct and anxiety?

AITA
Abbreviation for 'Am I the Asshole,' a popular Reddit community where users post personal dilemmas and ask strangers to judge who is at fault.
AITAH
A Reddit community similar to AITA ('Am I the Asshole'), used interchangeably in conversation to refer to relationship-dilemma posts.
Throwaway account
A temporary Reddit account created specifically to post sensitive or personal content anonymously, separate from a user's main account.
OP
Abbreviation for 'Original Poster' — the person who submitted a Reddit post or story being discussed.
Sunken cost fallacy
The tendency to continue investing in a failing relationship, project, or situation simply because of how much has already been invested, rather than its current value.
Terramation
Also called human composting or natural organic reduction, a process that converts human remains into soil through controlled decomposition; the hosts discussed it as an alternative to burial or cremation.
Aquamation
Also known as alkaline hydrolysis, a water-based alternative to cremation that uses water, heat, and alkaline chemicals to dissolve human remains into liquid.
Finsta
A secondary, private Instagram account (portmanteau of 'fake' and 'Instagram') used to share content with a smaller, trusted audience or anonymously.
Flush-mount bookcase
A bookcase installed flush to a wall, commonly used to conceal a hidden room or door behind what appears to be a normal shelf.
Gaslighting
A form of psychological manipulation in which someone causes another person to question their own perception, memory, or sanity; referenced when Morgan observed the therapy-letter poster seemed to have been gaslit into thinking mild thoughts were 'vicious.'
Retaliatory
Done in retaliation or revenge; Morgan used this to describe the husband's deliberate act of locking his pregnant wife outside as payback for disagreeing with him.
Stonewalling
A conflict behavior where one partner refuses to communicate or engage, effectively shutting down discussion; referenced as an example of emotional abuse.
Catastrophize
To imagine or assume the worst possible outcome in a situation; both Morgan and Taylor discussed their own past tendencies to catastrophize in relationships.
Tachycardia
A condition where the heart beats abnormally fast; Morgan joked she wished she could see Taylor's pulse via EKG during particularly stressful story moments.
Prodigal Daughter
Taylor Tomlinson's fourth Netflix stand-up special, announced on this episode as releasing February 24th.

Chapter 1 · 00:00

Start

The third story delivers the episode's most satisfying plot twist. A 22-year-old woman describes how her 23-year-old fiancé — who'd found a pregnancy test in his parents' bathroom weeks earlier — grabbed a champagne glass out of her hand at a New Year's party, then publicly accused her of risking 'the baby.' He proposed because he was 'stepping up.' She is absolutely not pregnant. The update confirms what Taylor Tomlinson clocked immediately: it was his mother's test. His mom was pregnant in her 40s and hadn't told anyone. The chaos unfolds in real time — the boyfriend genuinely thought he was doing the right thing, the girlfriend is left questioning whether she was only proposed to because he thought she was pregnant, and the mother's confession ends the standoff. The story becomes a launching pad for a deeply personal detour: Taylor reveals she spent years in therapy convinced a long-term boyfriend wasn't cheating on her — working through her 'paranoia' — only for him to admit years later he'd been seeing sex workers the whole time. Her first feeling was relief, not anger. She and Morgan then unpack the hard, important question: what's the difference between gut instinct and anxiety?

Claims made here

State Farm has over 19,000 local agents across the United States.

Morgan Absher no source cited

Taylor Tomlinson has released four Netflix stand-up specials, with 'Prodigal Daughter' releasing on February 24th.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

A Reddit post from 2015 described a woman finding a hidden digital camera in a biscuit tin under the kitchen sink containing paired photos of her belongings, with no update or resolution ever posted.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/Relationships, October 14, 2015

A Reddit post described a man who created an insurance-documentation theory as a plausible innocent explanation for photographing household items in pairs.

Morgan Absher no source cited

A 23-year-old man proposed to his 22-year-old girlfriend after finding a pregnancy test he believed was hers, which turned out to belong to his own mother who was pregnant in her 40s.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/AITAH

Taylor Tomlinson's younger sibling is very forgiving, empathetic, and gives everyone the benefit of the doubt, and being around them has made Taylor more positive.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

Taylor Tomlinson confirmed that an ex she had long suspected of cheating eventually admitted years later that he had been seeing sex workers throughout their relationship.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

A man arranged for his fiancée to be grabbed off the street and thrown into a moving escape room van as a birthday surprise, resulting in police involvement within 2 minutes.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/AITA

A Reddit comment about the snow lockout story received 6,000 upvotes and argued that the husband's behavior showed he separated his wife from her children and demonstrated to his daughters that men don't need to respect women.

Morgan Absher Reddit comments section, Am I Overreacting subreddit

Some countries, including Sweden, routinely leave babies outside in prams to nap in cold weather, even in snow.

Morgan Absher no source cited

A 31-year-old wife created fake Facebook and Instagram profiles impersonating her husband, friended approximately 30 of his exes and former flings, then deleted all evidence when confronted.

Morgan Absher Reddit post, March 27, 2018

Morgan Absher said she has 4 episodes scheduled across 3 days during an upcoming New York trip.

Morgan Absher no source cited

Society & Culture
The Hidden Camera Mystery — Art, Paranoia, or Something Worse?

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A woman found a hidden camera stashed in a biscuit tin under her kitchen sink, containing pairs of photos of her stuff — keys, coat, purse — with no update ever posted. Taylor sees romantic obsession; Morgan sees a true crime doc waiting to happen. The darkest theory: he's photographing her things so he can move them for a guest and put them back in exactly the right spot.

Society & Culture
The Secret Room — Should He Have Ever Told Her?

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A person built a secret room behind a flush-mount bookcase in their apartment before meeting their partner, then kept it secret for 8 months of cohabitation. When they finally revealed it, their fiancée was furious. Taylor's take: you should have never told her. Morgan's take: I'm scared there was a whole room I didn't know about.

Society & Culture
Data point 8 months

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026

A person hid a secret room behind a bookcase from their live-in partner for 8 months, only revealing it when their partner joked they needed a new room.

Society & Culture
The Fake Pregnancy That Was Actually His Mom's

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A 23-year-old man found a pregnancy test at his parents' house, assumed it was his girlfriend's, and publicly confronted her at a New Year's party before proposing because he was 'stepping up.' The test was his mother's. Taylor clocked it immediately; Morgan's mind went straight to side chick.

Society & Culture
Taylor Tomlinson on Why She Became More Positive

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

Taylor Tomlinson explained that she was once deeply jealous and negative, jumping to conclusions in ways that destroyed relationships. She was wrong often enough that she actively tried to give people the benefit of the doubt — and being around a younger sibling who is generous and empathetic has helped rewire her default reactions.

Health & Fitness
Taylor Tomlinson on Gut Feelings vs. Anxiety

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Health & Fitness

Taylor Tomlinson described how years of jealousy and catastrophizing in relationships taught her to distinguish gut feelings — which feel calm and grounded — from anxiety, which feels like panic. She only got there after being wrong enough times, and sometimes devastatingly right.

Society & Culture
The Sex Worker Revelation

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

Taylor Tomlinson worked through years of suspicion about an ex in therapy, convinced she was wrong to doubt him. Years later he told her he had been seeing sex workers the entire time. Her reaction: pure relief at being validated, not anger.

Society & Culture
Birthday Kidnapping Gone Very Wrong

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A man surprised his escape-room-obsessed fiancée by having her 'kidnapped' and thrown into a moving van. She escaped into a Dave Buster's, dropped her phone, screamed at him to run, and the cops showed up within 2 minutes. He still didn't understand what he did wrong.

Health & Fitness
The Therapy Letter He Was Never Supposed to Read

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Health & Fitness

A couples therapist assigned both partners an unsent letter exercise. The fiancé came home early, read his partner's letter addressed to his mother, declared it 'character assassination,' and demanded she apologize to his mom in person. Taylor's diagnosis: he went looking because he was ashamed of what he wrote about her.

Society & Culture
The Pregnant Wife Locked Outside in the Snow

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A husband locked his 6-months-pregnant wife outside for 25 minutes in the cold — while their toddler twins cried inside — to punish her for taking the kids out in the snow against his wishes. He opened the door smiling. Both Morgan and Taylor were alarmed, with Taylor wondering if he had a brain tumor.

Society & Culture
Data point 25 min

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026

A 26-year-old husband locked his 6-months-pregnant wife out of their home for 25 minutes as punishment for taking their toddler twins outside in the snow against his wishes.

Society & Culture
The Fake Facebook Stalker Wife

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A 31-year-old wife created fake Facebook and Instagram profiles in her husband's name, friended 30 of his exes and former flings, tried to dig up relationship dirt, then denied it, accused him of running the accounts, and deleted all evidence when caught. He's asking Reddit if it's time to leave.

No indexed bits in this chapter.

Show stoppers

Society & Culture
The Hidden Camera Mystery — Art, Paranoia, or Something Worse?

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

A woman found a hidden camera stashed in a biscuit tin under her kitchen sink, containing pairs of photos of her stuff — keys, coat, purse — with no update ever posted. Taylor sees romantic obsession; Morgan sees a true crime doc waiting to happen. The darkest theory: he's photographing her things so he can move them for a guest and put them back in exactly the right spot.

Society & Culture
The Sex Worker Revelation

256: That's Suspicious Ft. Taylor Tomlinson · Feb 19, 2026 Society & Culture

Taylor Tomlinson worked through years of suspicion about an ex in therapy, convinced she was wrong to doubt him. Years later he told her he had been seeing sex workers the entire time. Her reaction: pure relief at being validated, not anger.

Snapshots ()

Key Quotes ()

This episode

Cast

  • Track

Stats

Episode stats

Insight Overview

insights
chapters

Insight distribution

Sub-Categories

Speaker breakdown

Talk Time

This episode

Claims & Sources

5 / 12 cited (42%)

Factual claims made this episode, and whether a source was named.

Taylor Tomlinson has released four Netflix stand-up specials, with 'Prodigal Daughter' releasing on February 24th.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

State Farm has over 19,000 local agents across the United States.

Morgan Absher no source cited

Some countries, including Sweden, routinely leave babies outside in prams to nap in cold weather, even in snow.

Morgan Absher no source cited

Taylor Tomlinson's younger sibling is very forgiving, empathetic, and gives everyone the benefit of the doubt, and being around them has made Taylor more positive.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

A Reddit post from 2015 described a woman finding a hidden digital camera in a biscuit tin under the kitchen sink containing paired photos of her belongings, with no update or resolution ever posted.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/Relationships, October 14, 2015

A Reddit post described a man who created an insurance-documentation theory as a plausible innocent explanation for photographing household items in pairs.

Morgan Absher no source cited

A 23-year-old man proposed to his 22-year-old girlfriend after finding a pregnancy test he believed was hers, which turned out to belong to his own mother who was pregnant in her 40s.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/AITAH

A man arranged for his fiancée to be grabbed off the street and thrown into a moving escape room van as a birthday surprise, resulting in police involvement within 2 minutes.

Morgan Absher Reddit /r/AITA

A Reddit comment about the snow lockout story received 6,000 upvotes and argued that the husband's behavior showed he separated his wife from her children and demonstrated to his daughters that men don't need to respect women.

Morgan Absher Reddit comments section, Am I Overreacting subreddit

A 31-year-old wife created fake Facebook and Instagram profiles impersonating her husband, friended approximately 30 of his exes and former flings, then deleted all evidence when confronted.

Morgan Absher Reddit post, March 27, 2018

Taylor Tomlinson confirmed that an ex she had long suspected of cheating eventually admitted years later that he had been seeing sex workers throughout their relationship.

Taylor Tomlinson no source cited

Morgan Absher said she has 4 episodes scheduled across 3 days during an upcoming New York trip.

Morgan Absher no source cited