Podbit · The Ben Shapiro Show
Thomas doesn't reject Wong Kim Ark — he reinterprets it. The Chinese parents in that case couldn't renounce their Chinese citizenship (it meant death) and couldn't obtain American citizenship due to the Chinese Exclusion Act. They were effectively domiciled in the U.S., which is why their child was a citizen.
Where this was said
At 45:00 · chapter starts 33:20
This is the intellectual core of the episode. Shapiro walks through Thomas's 91-page stemwinder, the longest dissent Thomas has ever written, which systematically dismantles the Roberts majority's historical narrative. Thomas's core argument is that the Citizenship Clause was crafted to remedy one specific injustice — the denial of citizenship to Black Americans who had no other homeland, no foreign allegiance, and were permanently domiciled in the United States. Dred Scott denied them what was rightfully theirs; the 14th Amendment corrected that. But the same logic cannot apply to children of foreign temporary visitors, who are attached to their home countries and lack the bonds of permanent residence. Thomas argues the legal concept of domicile — one's permanent home — was so central to 19th-century citizenship law that it was considered synonymous with citizenship itself. Justice Bushrod Washington, he notes, equated domicile with citizenship explicitly. Under this framework, a baby born to Mexican parents who entered illegally, with the family's domicile remaining in Mexico, is no more American than the parents. Thomas also revisits Wong Kim Ark, arguing the Chinese parents in that case were effectively domiciled in the U.S. because the Chinese Exclusion Act barred them from both renouncing Chinese citizenship (on pain of death) and obtaining American citizenship — making them de facto stateless Americans. Shapiro declares Thomas's dissent 'dispositive' and 'very clearly correct.'
Roberts cited 128 years of precedent since United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898) as support for the birthright citizenship interpretation.
Thomas writes 91 pages to make one fundamental point: citizenship in America has always required domicile — that a place is your home. Birth alone was never enough. A baby dropped on U.S. soil by parents who owe allegiance to a foreign country was never, under the original meaning, an American citizen.
Thomas argued that the Chinese parents in Wong Kim Ark were effectively domiciled in the U.S. because the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 barred them from obtaining U.S. citizenship.
Factories that replaced coal engines with electric ones in the early 1900s got only 6% efficiency gains. Those that redesigned their entire factory around electricity got a 3x productivity improvement. Swapping AI tools into your existing structure will give you 6%. Rebuilding around AI will give you 10x.
Lebanese terrorists backed by Iran were holding American hostages throughout the Reagan presidency. Reagan had loudly campaigned against negotiating with terrorists — putting him in an impossible position that his team quietly decided to ignore.
During the Iran-Iraq War, the US openly supplied Iraq with weapons, training, and intelligence. At the same time, Oliver North was secretly funneling missiles to Iran. The US was playing both sides of a shooting war.
Oliver North traveled to Iran under the alias 'William P. Goode' with a fake passport. CIA Director William Casey allegedly gave him cyanide pills so he could kill himself rather than be tortured if captured. He returned safely and the deal moved forward.
The Pentagon sold missiles to the CIA for $3,700 each. The CIA sold them to Richard Secord at cost. Secord sold them to Iranian middleman Ghorbanifar for $10,000 each. Ghorbanifar charged Iran even more. The profit — including $3 million in interest in one Swiss account — was diverted directly to fund the Nicaraguan Contras.
America secretly transferred 2,000 missiles and missile parts to Iran in 8 shipments over more than a year. Only 3 of 7 hostages were released. Three more were taken. The net result was zero freed hostages and a full-blown constitutional scandal.
On October 5, 1986, a CIA Contra supply plane flew a weapons drop at 2,500 feet in broad daylight. A Sandinista soldier shot it down. The only survivor, Eugene Hasenfuss, had borrowed a parachute from his skydiving brother. He was captured, paraded in front of cameras, and told the Sandinistas everything he knew.
The CIA supply operation used a front company called Southern Air Transport, widely known to be a CIA cover. Crew members of the downed plane carried their Southern Air Transport employee IDs in their wallets. One also had a business card directly linking him to Oliver North's office in Washington.
When the scandal broke, Oliver North and his secretary Fawn Hall conducted what became known as a 'shredding party,' destroying a day's worth of documents. The full truth of Iran-Contra may never be known because of what was fed through that shredder.
We use essential and analytics cookies to run Vuci. To understand how the site is used: Privacy Policy.
Install Vuci on your phone
Add it to your home screen for a faster, app-like experience.
Install Vuci on your phone
Tap the Share button, then “Add to Home Screen”.
A new version is available
Reload to get the latest Vuci.