Modern Wisdom

Podbit · Modern Wisdom

The Most Important Questions Of Our Time - George Mack - #1124

Explore episode Jul 16, 2026

Where this was said

Should AI Be Winning Writing Awards?

At 12:21 · chapter starts 7:41

Chris walks through a detailed analysis of a suspicious Commonwealth Short Story Prize winner published in Granta magazine — a story a computer scientist found to be 'almost certainly not produced unaided by a human.' Specific phrases in the story, such as 'the patience of a reptile,' trace back to Naruto fan fiction, while other lines appear lifted from random horror blogs. The editor responded with a shrug. Chris's structural argument is sharp: LLMs don't simply learn from the best writing; they absorb whatever the internet has most of, and the internet has vastly more bad writing than good. He analogises it to a robot learning football by watching every human on Earth play — most of whom are terrible. George notes the coding vs. writing capability gap, suggesting that objective feedback loops (code either works or it doesn't) make coding easier to train toward quality than subjective literary taste.

Similar podbits