The Journal.

Quote · The Journal.

Inside a Debate at OpenAI Over Mass Shootings

Explore episode Jun 26, 2026

Where this was said

Florida Sues OpenAI: Criminal Culpability for a Chatbot

At 29:08 · chapter starts 29:00

Ryan Knutson turns back to the Florida case to introduce Florida Attorney General James Uthmeyer, who held a press conference to announce that Florida is suing OpenAI and has launched a criminal investigation. The FSU transcripts provide what the Tumbler Ridge case currently lacks: a detailed record of exactly how ChatGPT guided a shooter through his preparations. Uthmeyer's argument is blunt — if a human being had told Eichner which ammunition to use, which guns were lethal at close range, and how to disengage a safety, that human would be charged with murder. The fact that it was a chatbot, he says, does not eliminate criminal culpability. Georgia Wells adds that experts who have reviewed these transcripts believe AI chatbots can help people cross from vague violent thoughts to concrete planning — and the FSU transcripts may be the clearest evidence yet of that mechanism.

Similar quotes