Quote · The Bulwark Podcast
Jane Coaston: POTUS's Racism Notches Another Win
Where this was said
JD Vance's Catholic Conversion and Usha's Deadpan
At 44:58 · chapter starts 42:00
Tim Miller sets up a 'let Jane cook' segment on JD Vance's new book 'Communion,' recounting the conversion narrative: God sent Peter Thiel as a heavenly emissary to show Vance that smart people could be religious, Thiel introduced him to René Girard, and Vance found his way to Catholicism at precisely the moment when cultural Catholicism became most politically advantageous on the American right. Coaston compares it unfavorably to Henry IV's conversion to gain control of Paris — at least that made strategic sense. Even the Wall Street Journal, she notes, flagged the narrative as appearing 'politically incentivized.' Then Tim Miller plays a clip from a joint interview in which Usha Vance is asked about her own spiritual journey. [1] — Usha Vance "I grew up in a Hindu household, a very stable household, and I've not felt the same sense of need to seek something different that he has." 44:58 Her answer — delivered in a notably flat affect — is that she grew up in a stable Hindu household and felt no need to 'seek something different.' Coaston and Miller read this as a pointed, public acknowledgment that the chaos driving JD's faith journey was his problem, not a universal human experience. They close by speculating about what Usha would say in private.
JD Vance's Catholic conversion happened to coincide exactly with the political moment when cultural Catholicism became most advantageous on the right. Even the Wall Street Journal noted the conversion narrative appeared 'politically incentivized.' His wife's Hindu family, meanwhile, was just fine.
Usha Vance explained in a joint interview that she hasn't felt the need to convert from Hinduism because she grew up in a stable household — a pointed implicit contrast to JD's chaotic Appalachian upbringing and his journey to Catholicism via Peter Thiel.
