Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Snapshot · Crime, Conspiracy, Cults and Murder

Ep. 113 | The HORRIFIC Mushroom Murders

Explore episode Jun 3, 2026

Where this was said

The Investigation: Contradictions, Evidence and the Case Against Erin

At 41:30 · chapter starts 40:40

The investigation began formally on August 4, 2023 — the day Gail and Heather died — with Detective Sergeant Luke Farrell leading a search of Erin's Leongatha home the following morning. The contradictions stacked up quickly. Dr Chris Webster at the hospital had asked what mushrooms were in the meal; Erin said she bought them at Woolworths, which doesn't sell death caps. Her own blood work showed no clinical or biochemical signs of amanita poisoning despite her claim of being ill. Nurse Cindy Monroe noted she looked nothing like the other patients — Ian could barely lift his head while Erin sat upright in bed and left after five minutes to feed her dogs. CCTV footage from August 2 showed her driving to the Coonwarra tip with a Sunbeam food dehydrator; recovered two days later, it carried her fingerprints and traces of death cap mushroom. Friends had already given police screenshots of Facebook photos showing mushrooms on that dehydrator's trays. Forensic searches of her computer found iNaturalist searches for death cap sightings dating back to 2022, and cell tower data placed her phone near known death cap locations months before the lunch. Her phone was factory-reset four times — once while detectives were in the house, once remotely from a police evidence room. And the cancer she had disclosed to her family? Doctors found no record of any diagnosis, and her name was absent from the Victorian Cancer Registry.

Similar snapshots

Health & Fitness
Pipe broke → hydrogen sulfide studio air

Tortilla Face · Aug 10, 2026

A broken pipe filled the Bad Friends studio with what the hosts identified as hydrogen sulfide — microscopic fecal aeroparticles — that the crew denied smelling.