Speaker
Dr. Mike McCutcheon
Appearances over time
1 episodes
Episodes
1
Podcasts
Quotes & moments
Larry Millete's messages to spellcasters started with wanting Maya to love him again, then escalated to explicit sexual demands, requests to punish her, and even asking for her to suffer a broken bone. When Maya disappeared, every single spell request about her stopped immediately — a pattern prosecutors are using to argue he knew exactly where she was.
Larry Millete thought he was communicating with Tess Joy, a mystical blonde woman he met online. In court, the jury met Frank Peavey — an SEO worker by day who claimed to have joined a mystical coven in 1997 and earned a degree from a university that doesn't exist. He sent 27 messages a day to Larry; Frank says most clients send two.
The defense drilled one point in cross: not a single spell asked for Maya to disappear or die. Every purchase was about keeping her in Larry's life. It's a thin line between obsession and love — and the defense wants the jury to see a desperate husband, not a cold-blooded killer.
Maya Millete was having an affair with her married coworker Jamie Laird, whose wife was three months pregnant when it started. The anniversary of their affair was the same day Maya vanished. The next day, his wife gave birth. The defense wanted to point to Laird as the killer — but the judge ruled there wasn't enough evidence to bring it up in court.
Rex Heuermann walked into sentencing emotionless and left with 3 life sentences, no possibility of parole. The judge called him a 'disgusting, despicable small man' and a coward. Valerie Mack's family — including a son who spent years believing his mother abandoned him — spoke directly to the man who robbed him of his childhood.
Tracey Grist masterminded the ambush murder of Matthew Ristelli in 2024 by convincing her daughter to lure him to the house, where her son shot him. The judge called her 'incredibly dangerous' and sentenced her to 15 years to life, plus additional consecutive time. His brother told her she had destroyed her own grandchildren's future.
If a body is transported in a car rather than killed there, investigators use Luminol to detect cleaned-up blood and vehicle telematics to trace the route. But tracking a car to a gas station means pulling surveillance footage, identifying people, and cross-referencing every digital breadcrumb — a time-consuming process that can take months.
Faith Hedgepeth was 19 years old, a biology major at UNC, and a member of the Haliwa-Saponi Native American tribe. Her dream was to return home and become a pediatrician. She was temporarily sharing a one-bedroom apartment with her friend Karina while waiting on financial aid — and that apartment became the scene of her murder.
Next to Faith Hedgepeth's body, investigators found a handwritten note on a paper fast-food bag that read: 'I'm not stupid, bitch. Jealous.' The aggressive note pointed to a personal motive, yet when an arrest finally came nine years later, the accused killer had no known connection to Faith — deepening the mystery at the heart of the case.
The defense attorney for accused killer Miguel Salguero Olivares filed a motion arguing that Faith Hedgepeth's roommate Karina was still in the apartment when the medical examiner says Faith died at 2:51 AM. Karina said she left after 4 AM. There was also a 2-inch transfer bloodstain in the bathroom where Karina said she had been sitting — and a blood smudge reportedly spotted on her finger by the friend who drove her away.
A car has three forensic layers: the exterior, the interior, and the telematics. Unique tire characteristics can match a tread at a crime scene. Touchscreens collect fingerprints by design. And everyday trash — coffee cups, straws, receipts — can cross-reference a suspect's movements with GPS data to lock down a timeline.
Analysis
What they talk about
- True Crime 67%
- Technology 33%
Connections
Shows they appear on and people they share episodes with. Drag to explore.
