Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM?

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM?

Amazon buried a $40M Luca Guadagnino film about Sam Altman just weeks before festival season — and almost every other major studio has quietly passed on it too.

Jun 22, 2026 56:37 Difficulty: Intermediate Played

TL;DR

Amazon MGM Studios has dropped director Luca Guadagnino's nearly-finished film *Artificial* — starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman — amid speculation it clashed with Amazon's $50 billion investment partnership with OpenAI. Richard Osman and Marina Hyde dissect this as the most visible symptom of tech billionaires reshaping Hollywood's editorial independence. They then pivot to whether incoming UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham is Britain's first genuine indie-kid PM, based on his record collection. Tarantino's claim that no good films exist post-pandemic is cheerfully debunked with top-3 lists. Key takeaway: corporate self-censorship is now happening openly, not in the shadows.

#tech billionaire censorship #editorial independence #indie music authenticity #cultural canon lists #British Prime Minister #OpenAI investment #post-pandemic film #Hollywood distribution #politicians and pop culture #Manchester music scene #Hacienda nightclub #streaming vs cinema #digital media formats #Sam Altman portrayal #Sam Altman #OpenAI #Amazon #Luca Guadagnino #Artificial film #Andy Burnham #indie music #Quentin Tarantino #post-pandemic cinema #Hollywood censorship #tech billionaires #cultural lists #canon #New York Times #authenticity #British politics #The Pogues #Hacienda #The La's #Barbenheimer

Amazon MGM Studios dropped Luca Guadagnino's film Artificial about Sam Altman amid speculation of corporate censorship linked to Amazon's OpenAI deal. Richard Osman and Marina Hyde debate whether Andy Burnham is Britain's first indie-kid PM via his record collection, whether Tarantino is right about post-pandemic cinema, and why cultural lists now dominate digital media.

Chapter list
  • The episode kicks off with a tongue-in-cheek sponsor segment for Octopus Energy, with Richard Osman and Marina Hyde riffing on the strangeness of fan mail as a way into the idea that Octopus Energy actually responds to customers personally. Richard Osman describes it as 'almost unprecedented that a company you give your money to will actually respond to you.' The easyJet read follows, playfully built around the idea of getting distracted from a film's plot by its beautiful Mediterranean filming locations. The segment wraps with a medical ad for Peyronie's disease awareness and the talk-aboutpd.com resource before the hosts introduce themselves properly.

  • Richard Osman and Marina Hyde briefly set the scene, ticking off the three main items ahead: the dropped Luca Guadagnino film about Sam Altman; the question of whether incoming UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham is authentically an indie kid; and Quentin Tarantino's provocative claim that no good films have been made since the pandemic. It is a compact, punchy scene-setter that establishes the show's conversational register.

  • The conversation begins with Marina Hyde delivering a brisk character sketch of Sam Altman — 'the cold dead eyes of the boyfriend who joins in the search for the missing girlfriend' — before laying out the background: OpenAI began as a not-for-profit idealistic venture, but by Trump's second inauguration, Altman was seated in oligarchs' row, and OpenAI had become, in Hyde's words, 'a rapacious capitalist entity' that even Anthropic refused to partner with on defense contracts. The film Artificial, directed by Guadagnino, is based on the five extraordinary days in 2023 when Altman was ousted from OpenAI and then reinstated — a natural dramatic spine, with a stellar cast including Andrew Garfield as Altman and Ike Barinholtz as Elon Musk. Amazon financed it to near-completion at a cost of around $40 million, but then pulled out, claiming it might be 'better suited to another distributor.' Richard Osman explains the financial logic: at the point of release, Amazon would have been on the hook for another $40 million in marketing, while also having to promote the film using their own platform — a platform increasingly entangled with OpenAI to the tune of $50 billion. People who've seen early drafts report the Altman portrayal as 'intensely manipulative, a schemer, a power hoarder, a monomaniac', with Satya Nadella among the walk-on characters. The conversation draws a clear parallel with The Apprentice, the Trump biopic that also struggled to find a distributor despite clear awards potential, as an earlier symptom of the same pattern.

  • Richard Osman makes a careful distinction: Amazon releasing Artificial to another distributor is not the same as burying it entirely, and at least some countercultural money or distribution route might still exist. But Marina Hyde is less sanguine. She notes that the problem is now industry-wide — A24 and Netflix have also reportedly passed, and people she knows personally with projects about tech billionaires on the books at major studios are being quietly told, 'have you got something different?' Projects that were promised green lights after Trump's 2024 election have not materialised. The Social Reckoning, Aaron Sorkin's sequel to The Social Network, is coming in October, and Sorkin has noted he's only heard from Meta's lawyers asking him to 'just be careful.' But Peter Thiel — extremely litigious, with companies knit into the apparatus of multiple democratic states — has nothing even in development about him. Marina Hyde's conclusion is stark: the worst aspect of this moment is that the censorship is happening openly, not in the background. Studios are not shamefully hiding their capitulation — they are brazenly announcing it.

  • Richard Osman invokes historical optimism: when a culture becomes calcified and concentrated in a few hands — which has definitively happened now — that is precisely the moment when the fight-back begins. Creative people never change what stories they want to tell; they just need a different route to tell them. 'Creativity is still creativity. It will find a way through the dam. The water finds its way through the concrete.' He sees a gap in the market: Blumhouse-style lo-fi horror about tech barons, or a whole new wave of disruptive creators who haven't yet been bought. Marina Hyde is more cautious. She notes that you often have to live through a period of censorship or self-censorship first — and they are in that period now. The calculus has changed: studios aren't declining these projects because they don't want to offend powerful people outside their business, but because those powerful people are now inside their business, embedded in cloud infrastructure contracts. Both agree that the conclusion of all this is stark: American popular culture is definitively 'under the yoke of about five people, all of whom are billionaires and all of whom have quite thin skins.'

  • The Lloyds sponsor read is framed as a nostalgic trip to the optimism of the 1990s — Britpop, Oasis at Knebworth, Trainspotting, the Spice Girls — before landing on the point that mortgages were also more affordable. Lloyds is now offering £5,000 deposit mortgages to first-time buyers for the first time since 1996. The Cancer Research UK cross-promotion from The Rest Is Science describes CAR T-cell therapy, where doctors reprogram a patient's own T-cells to identify and destroy cancer cells, with particular promise in blood cancers and experimental work on solid tumours. A Carvana ad round completes the break.

  • Richard Osman begins by surveying the musical credentials of Burnham's predecessors: Cameron's advisors picked This Charming Man and Fake Plastic Trees for Desert Island Discs; Boris Johnson chose Pressure Drop; Kemi Badenoch went with Hamilton and Baz Luhrmann's Sunscreen. None of it passes the authenticity test. Burnham's Baker's Dozen in The Quietus is a different category entirely: The Beatles, Hatfield of Hollow by The Smiths (year zero of becoming an indie kid), Rum Sodomy and the Lash by the Pogues, the Stone Roses' debut, The La's, Billy Bragg's William Bloke, Radiohead's OK Computer, The Strokes, Big Thief's Capacity, New Order, and The Courteeners. What seals it, Osman argues, is the specificity: Burnham says he wants Sick Bed of Cuckoo Lane played at his funeral, he recalls going to the Hacienda on Thursday student nights (never the big Saturday rave nights), drinking lager and not taking ecstasy, and developing a friendship with Tony Wilson. 'There would be a few members of Inspiral Carpets hanging around,' Burnham told The Quietus — a sentence, Osman notes, that no British Prime Minister has ever uttered before. Marina Hyde adds that the mainstream equivalent — Keir Starmer's genuine love of football — paradoxically can't be used, because the public now reads every politician's cultural reference as a calculated focus-group play, creating what comms guru Kas Horowitz calls 'the ultimate high-stakes authenticity trap'.

  • Marina Hyde crystallises the paradox: Andy Burnham can be authentic about his record collection, but the moment he becomes Prime Minister he is the figurehead of a system, and coolness requires precisely the outsider status and ability to dream impossible dreams that politics forces you to surrender. The 'art of the possible' is definitively not cool. Richard Osman pivots to ask whether any politician has ever cleared the bar, landing on Barack Obama as the strongest candidate: his annual curated music lists featuring Kendrick Lamar, Chappell Roan, Rosalía, and Burna Boy are genuinely impressive — but almost too perfectly curated, raising the question of how many hands shaped them. Marina Hyde's counter-example is devastating: she once interviewed Nigel Farage and asked his favourite film, only to discover he could not recall the title of any film whatsoever. He eventually landed on Love Actually only after she supplied the name of Richard Curtis, and she is certain that Love Actually is not his favourite film. The anecdote becomes a meditation on the difference between having zero cultural hinterland (Farage) and a rich but politically undeployable one (Burnham, Starmer). The conclusion: 'if Barack Obama is not cool, then it is impossible for a politician to be cool.'

  • Marina Hyde notes that Tarantino himself probably doesn't fully mean what he said — it's a provocation, a piece of 'stupid shit' designed to spark a reaction, and it has worked magnificently. She pushes back substantively: Gen Z is returning to cinemas, the franchise IP correction is underway, and horror is in a particularly interesting moment. Both hosts find the claim untrue from personal experience and proceed to their top-3 lists. Marina Hyde: Nope (Jordan Peele's film about the compulsion to film danger), The Souvenir Part II (Joanna Hogg's semi-autobiographical masterpiece), and Oppenheimer — or really Barbenheimer as a phenomenon, arguing that its organic emergence proved the full range of what cinema could still achieve. Richard Osman: Rye Lane (a perfectly formed South London rom-com), The Holdovers (Alexander Payne, Paul Giamatti, tender and beautiful), and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (Tom Hiddleston, Tim Key — 'none of which outstay their welcome'). Osman acknowledges that Tarantino wants something visceral and shocking, and none of these films offer that — but 'if you have any sort of love in your heart, you would enjoy all three of them.'

  • Marina Hyde traces the genealogy of the canon list: from its 14th-century Biblical origins to the listicle era of BuzzFeed and on to the present moment, where the New York Times has made it a full-time C-suite appointment. The key insight is that these lists aren't just quick editorial products — they are the publication's most commercially successful outputs, generating evergreen traffic, driving book reprints, and repositioning legacy media brands as curators of taste in a noisy, crowded cultural landscape. The Guardian's ranked lists consistently outperform reviews; the New York Times' best books of the 21st century drove a rediscovery of Lonesome Dove. Richard Osman enthusiastically endorses the format, describing how the Guardian's top-100 books feature allowed readers to dig into individual critics' lists — navigating from the aggregate top 100 to Stephen King's personal favourites, for example — as a model for how lists can do more than just rank. He then announces his own forthcoming bonus episode series applying the same format to US sitcoms, UK game shows, and other categories, with the first instalment — the greatest US sitcom — featuring John Robbins and Maisie Adam and timed to honour the recently-deceased director James Burrows.

  • Richard Osman's recommendation is driven by the fact that Ingrid Bergès-Frisbey is currently filming an astronaut role, which led them to binge astronaut content; Return to Space, a Netflix documentary about SpaceX, is his pick for the week, praising the portrayal of the human endeavour behind spaceflight — and noting it contains scenes of Elon Musk appearing almost human. Marina Hyde's recommendation is deliberately petty by comparison: she wants everyone to watch the trailer for Pompeii: Out of Time, a Tom Hiddleston docudrama for National Geographic/Disney Plus in which he plays a time detective solving the mystery of Pompeii's final hours. Her delight at the intensity of Hiddleston's performance in the trailer is infectious. Her third pick is Roy Keane's rant on The Overlap, asked by Gary Neville to put something into football's Room 101: he chose WAGs who photograph themselves wearing their husbands' names on shirts, with the exception granted for players' children. The hosts wrap with a plug for Marina's Vibe Shift finale and the Thursday Q&A.

  • Richard Osman and Marina Hyde deliver the summer membership sale pitch: a third off an annual subscription to The Rest Is Entertainment with code SUMMER26, running until August 31st, giving access to ad-free listening, all bonus episodes including the Vibe Shift archive, and future members-only series. The closing ad slots go to Mint Mobile (Ryan Reynolds advertising unlimited wireless at $15/month) and Zocdoc (booking a doctor instantly by specialty, insurance, and availability).

Canon
In cultural usage, the body of works considered definitive or authoritative in a given field; originally a 14th-century term for Biblical texts accepted as genuine by the Christian Church.
Baker's Dozen
A feature run by music publication The Quietus in which a notable figure chooses and discusses their 13 favourite albums.
The Quietus
A UK independent music and culture publication known for in-depth, often leftfield coverage; considered a badge of indie credibility for contributors.
Spad
British shorthand for Special Adviser — a politically appointed aide to a government minister, typically involved in communications and strategy.
Overall deal
A contract arrangement in Hollywood where a writer or producer is paid by a studio for exclusive first-look or exclusive access to their output over a set period.
Listicle
A piece of online content structured as a list, popularised by platforms like BuzzFeed; typically shorter and more casual than ranked 'canon' lists.
Evergreen content
Digital content that remains relevant and continues to generate traffic long after its original publication date, such as ranked lists of best films or books.
Chinamaxxing
Slang for the cultural trend of young Western consumers turning increasingly to Chinese-origin entertainment, fashion, and media rather than American-dominated pop culture.
Franchise IP
Intellectual property tied to an established entertainment franchise (e.g. Marvel, Star Wars), used by studios as a commercial strategy favoring sequels and spin-offs over original content.
Extrajudicial killings
Killings carried out by a government outside any judicial procedure or legal oversight; referenced here as a criticism of Barack Obama's drone strike programme.
Bona fides
Latin for 'good faith'; used here to mean genuine credentials or proof of authenticity — specifically evidence that Andy Burnham's indie tastes are real, not manufactured.
Cultural hinterland
A person's breadth of genuine cultural interests and knowledge beyond their professional role; used in British public life to describe politicians who engage seriously with arts and ideas.
Spec scriptwriter
A screenwriter who writes scripts on speculation without a commission, hoping to sell them; contrasted here with established writers on studio 'overall deals'.
Calcified
Rigidly set and resistant to change; used metaphorically by Richard Osman to describe a cultural and financial landscape locked down by a small number of powerful actors.
Yoke
A wooden crosspiece constraining movement; used metaphorically here ('under the yoke of') to mean subjugated or controlled by an external power.
Litigious
Prone to engaging in or threatening legal action; used to describe Peter Thiel's aggressive use of lawsuits against journalists and media organisations.
Perfunctory
Carried out with minimal effort and only as a routine duty; implied in the discussion of fan mail and pro-forma celebrity replies.
Bogeyman
An imaginary or real figure used to inspire fear or as a target of blame; used here to describe how tech billionaires function as compelling but troubling subjects for creative projects.

Chapter 2 · 02:59

Intro & Episode Roadmap

Richard Osman and Marina Hyde briefly set the scene, ticking off the three main items ahead: the dropped Luca Guadagnino film about Sam Altman; the question of whether incoming UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham is authentically an indie kid; and Quentin Tarantino's provocative claim that no good films have been made since the pandemic. It is a compact, punchy scene-setter that establishes the show's conversational register.

Business
Amazon Drops Luca Guadagnino's Artificial

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Business

Amazon has dropped Luca Guadagnino's nearly-finished film Artificial, starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman, reportedly because Amazon is simultaneously pouring $50 billion into OpenAI. The studio says it may be 'better suited to another distributor' — but the financial entanglement tells a clearer story.

Chapter 3 · 03:40

Amazon Drops Artificial: Corporate Censorship or Good Business?

The conversation begins with Marina Hyde delivering a brisk character sketch of Sam Altman — 'the cold dead eyes of the boyfriend who joins in the search for the missing girlfriend' — before laying out the background: OpenAI began as a not-for-profit idealistic venture, but by Trump's second inauguration, Altman was seated in oligarchs' row, and OpenAI had become, in Hyde's words, 'a rapacious capitalist entity' that even Anthropic refused to partner with on defense contracts. The film Artificial, directed by Guadagnino, is based on the five extraordinary days in 2023 when Altman was ousted from OpenAI and then reinstated — a natural dramatic spine, with a stellar cast including Andrew Garfield as Altman and Ike Barinholtz as Elon Musk. Amazon financed it to near-completion at a cost of around $40 million, but then pulled out, claiming it might be 'better suited to another distributor.' Richard Osman explains the financial logic: at the point of release, Amazon would have been on the hook for another $40 million in marketing, while also having to promote the film using their own platform — a platform increasingly entangled with OpenAI to the tune of $50 billion. People who've seen early drafts report the Altman portrayal as 'intensely manipulative, a schemer, a power hoarder, a monomaniac', with Satya Nadella among the walk-on characters. The conversation draws a clear parallel with The Apprentice, the Trump biopic that also struggled to find a distributor despite clear awards potential, as an earlier symptom of the same pattern.

Claims made here

OpenAI originally started as a not-for-profit organisation.

Marina Hyde no source cited

In 2016, Sam Altman publicly compared Trump's rise to the 1930s, saying it was 'absolutely chilling'.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Anthropic declined to take on US defense contracts that OpenAI accepted.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Luca Guadagnino directed Call Me by Your Name and Challengers.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The Luca Guadagnino film Artificial cost approximately $40 million to produce.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Sam Altman was a guest at the Bezos-Sánchez wedding.

Richard Osman no source cited

Amazon is investing approximately $50 billion in OpenAI.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Amazon previously signed a $38 billion cloud partnership with OpenAI.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The film Artificial was reportedly far darker than Amazon anticipated, with particularly bleak portrayals of both Sam Altman and Elon Musk.

Richard Osman no source cited

Business
Data point $40M

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

The Luca Guadagnino film Artificial, which Amazon dropped before release, reportedly cost around $40 million to produce.

Business
Data point $50B

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Amazon is investing approximately $50 billion in OpenAI, creating a conflict of interest that likely explains why they dropped the Luca Guadagnino film about Sam Altman.

Business
Data point ~$80M

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Richard Osman pointed out that Amazon would have faced a total outlay of around $80 million — $40M production plus $40M marketing — had they proceeded with Artificial.

Chapter 4 · 14:00

The Pattern of Self-Censorship Across Hollywood

Richard Osman makes a careful distinction: Amazon releasing Artificial to another distributor is not the same as burying it entirely, and at least some countercultural money or distribution route might still exist. But Marina Hyde is less sanguine. She notes that the problem is now industry-wide — A24 and Netflix have also reportedly passed, and people she knows personally with projects about tech billionaires on the books at major studios are being quietly told, 'have you got something different?' Projects that were promised green lights after Trump's 2024 election have not materialised. The Social Reckoning, Aaron Sorkin's sequel to The Social Network, is coming in October, and Sorkin has noted he's only heard from Meta's lawyers asking him to 'just be careful.' But Peter Thiel — extremely litigious, with companies knit into the apparatus of multiple democratic states — has nothing even in development about him. Marina Hyde's conclusion is stark: the worst aspect of this moment is that the censorship is happening openly, not in the background. Studios are not shamefully hiding their capitulation — they are brazenly announcing it.

Claims made here

Amazon paid $75 million for a documentary about Melania Trump directed by Brett Ratner.

Marina Hyde no source cited

A24 and Netflix have both reportedly passed on distributing Artificial.

Richard Osman trade papers

Business
The Counterfactual for Amazon

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Business

Richard Osman makes a measured counterpoint: Amazon releasing the film to another distributor is actually less sinister than if they'd simply buried it and withheld rights. The problem is the pattern — the fact that the industry now structurally avoids these projects before they even begin.

TV & Film
The Film No One Will Touch

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 TV & Film

Beyond Amazon's original drop, A24 and Netflix have also reportedly passed on distributing Artificial. A movie with an impeccable creative team — Guadagnino directing, Andrew Garfield starring — is becoming an industry-wide pariah, which is arguably more chilling than any single studio decision.

Technology
Tech Giants Are Rewriting Hollywood's Rules

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Technology

The creative industries are caving to tech giants not out of political cowardice but because cloud infrastructure deals make dissent financially suicidal. Studios can't exist without the tech firms — and that dependency is now bending editorial decisions in cinema, news, and late-night television simultaneously.

Chapter 5 · 18:20

Can Creativity Fight Back? Richard Osman's Optimism

Richard Osman invokes historical optimism: when a culture becomes calcified and concentrated in a few hands — which has definitively happened now — that is precisely the moment when the fight-back begins. Creative people never change what stories they want to tell; they just need a different route to tell them. 'Creativity is still creativity. It will find a way through the dam. The water finds its way through the concrete.' He sees a gap in the market: Blumhouse-style lo-fi horror about tech barons, or a whole new wave of disruptive creators who haven't yet been bought. Marina Hyde is more cautious. She notes that you often have to live through a period of censorship or self-censorship first — and they are in that period now. The calculus has changed: studios aren't declining these projects because they don't want to offend powerful people outside their business, but because those powerful people are now inside their business, embedded in cloud infrastructure contracts. Both agree that the conclusion of all this is stark: American popular culture is definitively 'under the yoke of about five people, all of whom are billionaires and all of whom have quite thin skins.'

Arts
The Last Swish of the Dinosaur's Tail

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Arts

Richard Osman argues that cultural calcification — when money and power concentrate in a few hands — historically triggers creative explosions from the next generation. The current stranglehold of tech billionaires may be the dinosaur's last swish, not a permanent new order.

Society & Culture
Data point ~5

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Richard Osman argued that American popular culture is now definitively controlled by approximately five billionaires, all of whom have thin skins.

Chapter 7 · 26:03

Andy Burnham: Britain's First Indie-Kid Prime Minister?

Richard Osman begins by surveying the musical credentials of Burnham's predecessors: Cameron's advisors picked This Charming Man and Fake Plastic Trees for Desert Island Discs; Boris Johnson chose Pressure Drop; Kemi Badenoch went with Hamilton and Baz Luhrmann's Sunscreen. None of it passes the authenticity test. Burnham's Baker's Dozen in The Quietus is a different category entirely: The Beatles, Hatfield of Hollow by The Smiths (year zero of becoming an indie kid), Rum Sodomy and the Lash by the Pogues, the Stone Roses' debut, The La's, Billy Bragg's William Bloke, Radiohead's OK Computer, The Strokes, Big Thief's Capacity, New Order, and The Courteeners. What seals it, Osman argues, is the specificity: Burnham says he wants Sick Bed of Cuckoo Lane played at his funeral, he recalls going to the Hacienda on Thursday student nights (never the big Saturday rave nights), drinking lager and not taking ecstasy, and developing a friendship with Tony Wilson. 'There would be a few members of Inspiral Carpets hanging around,' Burnham told The Quietus — a sentence, Osman notes, that no British Prime Minister has ever uttered before. Marina Hyde adds that the mainstream equivalent — Keir Starmer's genuine love of football — paradoxically can't be used, because the public now reads every politician's cultural reference as a calculated focus-group play, creating what comms guru Kas Horowitz calls 'the ultimate high-stakes authenticity trap'.

Society & Culture
Is Andy Burnham Actually Cool?

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Richard Osman makes the case that incoming British PM Andy Burnham is the genuine article: his Baker's Dozen list in The Quietus includes Rum Sodomy and the Lash, George Best by The Wedding Present, and Big Thief's Capacity — the kind of choices no political advisor would ever greenlight. Authenticity confirmed.

Society & Culture
Data point 13

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Andy Burnham participated in The Quietus's Baker's Dozen feature, choosing his 13 favourite albums, which Richard Osman used as evidence of his authentic indie credentials.

Society & Culture
Data point 1970

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Andy Burnham was born in the same year as Richard Osman, which Osman used humorously to decode the generational authenticity of Burnham's record collection.

Society & Culture
Andy Burnham and the Hacienda

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Andy Burnham used to go to the Hacienda on Thursday nights — student night — drinking lager, and claims he never took ecstasy. Richard Osman notes that no British Prime Minister has ever referenced Inspiral Carpets before, and that Burnham's friendship with Tony Wilson adds further credibility to his Northern cultural mythology.

Chapter 8 · 35:30

Can a Politician Ever Be Cool? Obama, Farage, and the Paradox

Marina Hyde crystallises the paradox: Andy Burnham can be authentic about his record collection, but the moment he becomes Prime Minister he is the figurehead of a system, and coolness requires precisely the outsider status and ability to dream impossible dreams that politics forces you to surrender. The 'art of the possible' is definitively not cool. Richard Osman pivots to ask whether any politician has ever cleared the bar, landing on Barack Obama as the strongest candidate: his annual curated music lists featuring Kendrick Lamar, Chappell Roan, Rosalía, and Burna Boy are genuinely impressive — but almost too perfectly curated, raising the question of how many hands shaped them. Marina Hyde's counter-example is devastating: she once interviewed Nigel Farage and asked his favourite film, only to discover he could not recall the title of any film whatsoever. He eventually landed on Love Actually only after she supplied the name of Richard Curtis, and she is certain that Love Actually is not his favourite film. The anecdote becomes a meditation on the difference between having zero cultural hinterland (Farage) and a rich but politically undeployable one (Burnham, Starmer). The conclusion: 'if Barack Obama is not cool, then it is impossible for a politician to be cool.'

Society & Culture
Politicians and the Authenticity Trap

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Even authentic cultural interests become liabilities for politicians the moment they're perceived as calculated. Keir Starmer genuinely loves football but barely mentions it — because the public now assumes any cultural reference is a focus-group play. Authenticity is the most important quality, and also the easiest to destroy.

Society & Culture
Nigel Farage Couldn't Name a Film

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Marina Hyde recounts asking Nigel Farage his favourite film — and discovering he couldn't recall the title of any film at all, eventually settling on Love Actually only after she supplied the director's name. The anecdote crystallises what she sees as a complete absence of genuine cultural life.

Society & Culture
Obama: The Closest a Politician Has Got to Cool

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Richard Osman argues Obama is the most credible candidate for a cool politician — with genuinely extraordinary curated music lists featuring Kendrick Lamar, Chappell Roan, and Rosalía. But the curation is so perfect it raises its own questions. If even Obama isn't quite cool, no politician ever will be.

Chapter 9 · 41:00

Tarantino Says No Good Films Since the Pandemic — Is He Right?

Marina Hyde notes that Tarantino himself probably doesn't fully mean what he said — it's a provocation, a piece of 'stupid shit' designed to spark a reaction, and it has worked magnificently. She pushes back substantively: Gen Z is returning to cinemas, the franchise IP correction is underway, and horror is in a particularly interesting moment. Both hosts find the claim untrue from personal experience and proceed to their top-3 lists. Marina Hyde: Nope (Jordan Peele's film about the compulsion to film danger), The Souvenir Part II (Joanna Hogg's semi-autobiographical masterpiece), and Oppenheimer — or really Barbenheimer as a phenomenon, arguing that its organic emergence proved the full range of what cinema could still achieve. Richard Osman: Rye Lane (a perfectly formed South London rom-com), The Holdovers (Alexander Payne, Paul Giamatti, tender and beautiful), and The Ballad of Buster Scruggs (Tom Hiddleston, Tim Key — 'none of which outstay their welcome'). Osman acknowledges that Tarantino wants something visceral and shocking, and none of these films offer that — but 'if you have any sort of love in your heart, you would enjoy all three of them.'

Claims made here

Quentin Tarantino said there have been no good movies since the pandemic, describing post-pandemic films as defined by flaws, implausibilities, audience pandering, miscast performers, or plain stupidity.

Marina Hyde no source cited

TV & Film
Tarantino vs Post-Pandemic Cinema

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 TV & Film

Tarantino declared there have been no good films since the pandemic. Marina Hyde and Richard Osman push back — cheerfully, with their own top-3 lists. The real issue isn't whether good films exist; it's why Tarantino's provocation spawned a thousand lists and what that reveals about how media now works.

Chapter 10 · 45:20

The Rise of the Cultural Canon List

Marina Hyde traces the genealogy of the canon list: from its 14th-century Biblical origins to the listicle era of BuzzFeed and on to the present moment, where the New York Times has made it a full-time C-suite appointment. The key insight is that these lists aren't just quick editorial products — they are the publication's most commercially successful outputs, generating evergreen traffic, driving book reprints, and repositioning legacy media brands as curators of taste in a noisy, crowded cultural landscape. The Guardian's ranked lists consistently outperform reviews; the New York Times' best books of the 21st century drove a rediscovery of Lonesome Dove. Richard Osman enthusiastically endorses the format, describing how the Guardian's top-100 books feature allowed readers to dig into individual critics' lists — navigating from the aggregate top 100 to Stephen King's personal favourites, for example — as a model for how lists can do more than just rank. He then announces his own forthcoming bonus episode series applying the same format to US sitcoms, UK game shows, and other categories, with the first instalment — the greatest US sitcom — featuring John Robbins and Maisie Adam and timed to honour the recently-deceased director James Burrows.

Claims made here

The New York Times appointed Gilbert Cruz as their first-ever Head of Canon.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The word 'canon' in its cultural sense originated in the 1300s referring to Biblical texts accepted as genuine by the Christian Church.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The Manchester Guardian in 1933 discussed whether a Sherlock Holmes story containing the words 'elementary, my dear Watson' was part of the official Sherlock Holmes canon.

Marina Hyde Manchester Guardian, 1933

News
The Rise of the Cultural Canon List

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 News

The New York Times has created the role of Head of Canon, appointing Gilbert Cruz to manage their curated ranking products. These lists — from best novels to best films — now outperform reviews commercially, last longer as evergreen content, and have become the publication's most powerful market-moving cultural products.

History
Data point 1300s

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026

Marina Hyde traced the word 'canon' back to the 1300s, when it referred to the collection of Biblical books accepted as genuine by the Christian Church, before evolving into its modern cultural usage.

No indexed bits in this chapter.

Show stoppers

Business
Amazon Drops Luca Guadagnino's Artificial

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Business

Amazon has dropped Luca Guadagnino's nearly-finished film Artificial, starring Andrew Garfield as Sam Altman, reportedly because Amazon is simultaneously pouring $50 billion into OpenAI. The studio says it may be 'better suited to another distributor' — but the financial entanglement tells a clearer story.

Society & Culture
Is Andy Burnham Actually Cool?

Andy Burnham - Our First Indie-Kid PM? · Jun 22, 2026 Society & Culture

Richard Osman makes the case that incoming British PM Andy Burnham is the genuine article: his Baker's Dozen list in The Quietus includes Rum Sodomy and the Lash, George Best by The Wedding Present, and Big Thief's Capacity — the kind of choices no political advisor would ever greenlight. Authenticity confirmed.

Snapshots ()

Key Quotes ()

This episode

Cast

  • Track
  • Track
  • Track

Stats

Episode stats

Insight Overview

insights
chapters

Insight distribution

Sub-Categories

Speaker breakdown

Talk Time

This episode

Claims & Sources

2 / 15 cited (13%)

Factual claims made this episode, and whether a source was named.

Amazon is investing approximately $50 billion in OpenAI.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Amazon previously signed a $38 billion cloud partnership with OpenAI.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The Luca Guadagnino film Artificial cost approximately $40 million to produce.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Sam Altman was a guest at the Bezos-Sánchez wedding.

Richard Osman no source cited

In 2016, Sam Altman publicly compared Trump's rise to the 1930s, saying it was 'absolutely chilling'.

Marina Hyde no source cited

OpenAI originally started as a not-for-profit organisation.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Anthropic declined to take on US defense contracts that OpenAI accepted.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The film Artificial was reportedly far darker than Amazon anticipated, with particularly bleak portrayals of both Sam Altman and Elon Musk.

Richard Osman no source cited

A24 and Netflix have both reportedly passed on distributing Artificial.

Richard Osman trade papers

Amazon paid $75 million for a documentary about Melania Trump directed by Brett Ratner.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The New York Times appointed Gilbert Cruz as their first-ever Head of Canon.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The word 'canon' in its cultural sense originated in the 1300s referring to Biblical texts accepted as genuine by the Christian Church.

Marina Hyde no source cited

The Manchester Guardian in 1933 discussed whether a Sherlock Holmes story containing the words 'elementary, my dear Watson' was part of the official Sherlock Holmes canon.

Marina Hyde Manchester Guardian, 1933

Luca Guadagnino directed Call Me by Your Name and Challengers.

Marina Hyde no source cited

Quentin Tarantino said there have been no good movies since the pandemic, describing post-pandemic films as defined by flaws, implausibilities, audience pandering, miscast performers, or plain stupidity.

Marina Hyde no source cited