The 14-point Israel-Lebanon peace agreement does not include the word 'withdraw' and does not specify a timeframe for Israeli withdrawal.
Keeping Up With the Korruption in Kazakhstan
Nicholas Kristof names children who died because USAID ambulances ran out of diesel — directly rebutting Elon Musk's claim that "not a single person" died from DOGE's cuts to foreign aid.
Pod Save the World
Keeping Up With the Korruption in Kazakhstan
Nicholas Kristof names children who died because USAID ambulances ran out of diesel — directly rebutting Elon Musk's claim that "not a single person" died from DOGE's cuts to foreign aid.
TL;DR
Tommy Vietor and Ben Rhodes unpack a turbulent week: a fragile 14-point Israel-Lebanon peace deal that excludes Hezbollah [1] — Ben Rhodes "Iran's real strategic prize from the US-Iran conflict isn't sanctions relief or even a nuclear program — it's permanent control of the Stra…" 15:35 , a US-Iran ceasefire riddled with airstrikes and competing narratives about who controls the Strait of Hormuz, and a stunning corruption story linking Trump and Lutnick family members to a Kazakhstan tungsten deal worth $1.6 billion in federal financing [2] — Ben Rhodes "Ben Rhodes traces the Kazakhstan corruption story back to its roots in post-Soviet oligarchic capitalism, where resources were gifted to wh…" 28:03 . Supreme Court rulings on birthright citizenship and Temporary Protected Status threaten hundreds of thousands of Haitians and Syrians [3] — Tommy Vietor "Venezuela's catastrophic earthquakes — 1,700+ dead, 50,000 missing — are testing Delcy Rodriguez's interim government in ways that expose h…" 43:10 . Tommy's interview with NYT columnist Nicholas Kristof delivers a searing rebuttal to Elon Musk's claim that USAID cuts killed nobody — Kristof names children he personally reported on who died [4] — Nicholas Kristof "The Lancet estimates 9.4 million additional deaths by 2030 from USAID cuts. A Boston University tracker puts current deaths above 780,000. …" 1:21:57 .
Tommy Vietor and Ben Rhodes cover a turbulent week: the Israel-Lebanon 14-point peace deal, the fragile US-Iran ceasefire riddled with airstrikes, a Kazakhstan corruption scandal involving Trump and Lutnick family members and $1.6B in federal financing, Supreme Court rulings on birthright citizenship and TPS for Haitians and Syrians, devastating earthquakes in Venezuela, France's air conditioning debate during a deadly heat wave, World Cup upsets, and an interview with NYT columnist Nicholas Kristof rebutting Elon Musk's claim that USAID cuts killed nobody.
-
The episode opens with a sponsor read for Remi, the FDA-cleared at-home night guard company. Tommy and Ben riff about jaw clenching and teeth grinding before walking through how the product works: an impression kit ships to your door, you make the mold at home, send it back, and receive a custom-fit night guard. The duo also touts the Remi Club subscription that sends a replacement every six months. Promo code PSTW at shopremi.com/PSTW delivers 55% off through the end of August.
-
Two short sponsor reads fill this segment. Nordstrom Rack promotes summer arrivals with up to 60% off brands like Rag & Bone and Adidas, highlighting the Nordy Club loyalty program and free in-store pickup. Colgate Total then draws an analogy between buckling a seatbelt and using their toothpaste to prevent oral health problems before they start.
-
Tommy Vietor opens the main episode as Ben Rhodes dials in remotely after approximately five weeks on the road promoting his book, which has now spent four weeks on the bestseller list. Tommy previews the episode's remarkable breadth: a Washington-signed Israel-Lebanon peace agreement, the ongoing US-Iran ceasefire-in-name-only, a Kazakhstan corruption scandal involving both the Trump and Lutnick families, Supreme Court rulings on birthright citizenship and TPS, the Venezuela earthquake, the French air conditioning culture war, World Cup agonies, and an interview with New York Times columnist Nicholas Kristof about Elon Musk's insistence that USAID cuts killed nobody. The teased Easter egg about Ben's location — Amsterdam — sets up the World Cup segment later in the show.
-
Tommy walks through the mechanics of the 14-point deal: phased Lebanese Armed Forces takeover of pilot zones, Lebanon's pledge to reject Hezbollah's security role, and a framework for eventual IDF withdrawal without any specified timeline. Skepticism is immediate and comes from all sides. Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir called it a 'historic mistake.' Defense Minister Katz said Israel won't withdraw a millimeter until Hezbollah disarms. Lebanese officials with and without Hezbollah ties called it a humiliation that could trigger civil war or legitimize a long occupation. Ben Rhodes frames the deal bluntly: you cannot disarm Hezbollah with an agreement Hezbollah didn't sign. The real purpose, he argues, is face-saving diplomacy to allow the US-Iran MOU to move forward — not a genuine solution to a conflict that has killed at least 4,000 Lebanese civilians.
-
Tommy details the week's timeline: Iran fires an attack drone at a tanker for taking the 'wrong' route through the Strait; the US retaliates by hitting Iranian missile and drone sites; Iran attacks another tanker; the US strikes again; Trump threatens on Truth Social that 'the Islamic Republic of Iran will no longer exist'; the IRGC fires at US bases in Bahrain and Kuwait, killing a Qatari national; then Witkoff and Kushner head to Doha for talks Iran says they only attend to discuss frozen assets. Ben Rhodes delivers the strategic verdict: Iran has secured something more valuable than nuclear deterrence — control of 20% of the world's energy supply, with a future fee-collection model in mind. Jennifer Griffin's Fox News reporting, commended by Rhodes for its quality, confirms the US had to restrike because Iran already rebuilt its missile defenses since the ceasefire — undermining any claim of lasting military victory. Tommy adds that tanker traffic is still only 70% of pre-war levels and the global oil cost to consumers was likely $60-70 billion in extra spending.
-
Squarespace's ad highlights Blueprint AI, custom domains at flat pricing, and a 10% discount for new subscribers at squarespace.com/world. The Power Plays cross-promotion is unusually substantive — a five-episode series tracing the political history of the FIFA World Cup from Mussolini's 1934 Italy through Putin's Russia, Qatar, and the 2026 US tournament, with a look ahead to Saudi Arabia in 2034. Given the episode's World Cup thread, the placement is editorial as much as promotional.
-
Tommy lays out the anatomy of the Kazakhstan deal: a company called Kaz Resources gets access to the world's largest untapped tungsten reserve after Trump-level diplomatic pressure on Kazakhstan's president; a Trump sons-affiliated firm called Dominari Securities takes a 20% stake; Howard Lutnick's kids at Cantor Fitzgerald raise $210M and pocket millions in fees; and the administration then approves $1.6B in federal financing for the project. The Times found this is not an isolated scandal — the Trump and Lutnick families have financial ties to at least 14 similar mining deals. Ben Rhodes connects the dots historically, tracing the template back to post-Soviet oligarchic capitalism in Central Asia, where political power and natural resources were bundled into family business from day one. He notes Trump literally hosted a Central Asian summit — held while Crooked Con was in the same hotel — that now reads as a deal-structuring event. The parallel corruption of Donald Trump Jr.'s Vulcan Elements investment, which 10x'd after a $600M Pentagon injection, confirms the pattern. Rhodes names it directly: this is the Epstein class running America's defense supply chain.
-
Tommy frames the birthright ruling as good news that shouldn't require celebration — the plain text of the 14th Amendment is not ambiguous — but notes the effective margin was 5-4 because Kavanaugh agreed with the outcome while declining to join the majority opinion, signaling a future path to reversal. The TPS ruling is less ambiguous as good news: 350,000 Haitians are being sent back to a country the State Department rates 'do not travel,' where gangs control major territory and half the population faces acute hunger, while white South Afrikaners receive welcome bags full of revisionist history books. Ben Rhodes invokes Frederick Douglass to skewer conservative originalists for ignoring the 14th Amendment's actual authors, who clearly intended universal birthright citizenship. He and Tommy both call the TPS ruling what it is: straightforwardly racist, constitutionally rationalized. Rhodes adds that Venezuelan TPS holders who supported Republican policies because of Maduro opposition have now been told exactly what the party thinks of them.
-
Tommy recaps the scale of the disaster: 1,700+ casualties, 50,000 missing, and a humanitarian response that looks nothing like the 17,000 US military personnel mobilized for Haiti in 2010. The Trump administration pledged $300 million and 300+ search-and-rescue personnel, but the context is radically worse: a healthcare infrastructure already decimated, USAID dismantled, and an international aid system hollowed out. Crowds jeered Rodriguez at disaster sites, chanting 'get out'; Venezuela's own military was conspicuously absent while citizens dug through rubble by hand. Ben Rhodes argues that the Maduro removal was never about democratic transformation — it was tribute extraction, with Trump people doing oil and real estate deals rather than building a responsive government. He draws a direct parallel to the 2010 Haiti earthquake, which killed 310,000 people and ultimately collapsed the Haitian government even with a functioning USAID. He warns that the combination of an unreformed repressive government, a shattered trust, and a gutted international response system makes Venezuela's trajectory very dangerous.
-
Incogni is pitched as an automated data broker opt-out service that continuously monitors and removes personal data, independently verified by Deloitte; listeners get 60% off an annual plan with code PSTW at incogni.com/PSTW with a 30-day money-back guarantee. Ridge follows with a pitch for its slim aluminum, titanium, and carbon fiber wallets — holding up to 12 cards, with a tracker card, lifetime warranty, and 10% off with code PSTW at ridge.com.
-
Tommy lays out the cultural stakes first: only 25% of French households have AC, and the arguments against expanding it range from environmental (it heats cities and uses energy) to identity-based (France will lose its outdoor culture). Then the political circus: Marine Le Pen is running on 'AC for All' while Jean-Luc Mélenchon opposes public building cooling and Macron's ecological minister says she's 'horrified' by AC proposals. The absurdity peaks when Tommy reports a Parisian hospital where 27 of 30 wards had no AC and temperatures reached 95 degrees, with staff telling patients to bring fans to the maternity ward. A French influencer video showing food being cooked on a window ledge in the sun illustrates just how hot it actually is. Ben Rhodes, who spent a week in 100-degree London without any AC and watched a heat conference get canceled because of the heat, frames the political lesson clearly: use the heat to argue for a clean energy transition, but do not oppose air conditioning in public buildings. Workers riding un-air-conditioned buses need relief now. The left will hand Marine Le Pen the Élysée if they choose this hill.
-
Tommy rattles through the elimination highlights: Germany beaten by Paraguay on penalties; the Netherlands eliminated by Morocco also on penalties in a game Ben slept through until 5 AM Amsterdam time when the city's collective anxiety woke him up; Uruguay eliminated with their soccer federation canceling the charter flight home as punishment; and South Korea's catastrophic exit — needing only a draw against lower-ranked South Africa and losing — that has prompted a presidential investigation and airport jeering. Ben describes wandering around Amsterdam the night before the Dutch game, seeing boats with big screen TVs and fully stocked bars, then waking at 5 AM to every penalty kick being accompanied by citywide honking and shouting. When the Netherlands lost, he heard 'a lot of drunk people making very unpleasant noises' and refused to leave his hotel. He also reveals he's in Amsterdam on vacation after his book tour, which was this episode's teased Easter egg. Both hosts praise Morocco's run as part of a broader African teams story and a meaningful anti-colonial sporting narrative.
-
SimpliSafe leads with a pitch on its AI-powered cameras that deter intruders before break-ins begin, with John Lovett cited as a real user; 50% off at simplisafe.com/crookedworld. ThirdLove promotes bras designed for comfort across 60+ sizes including half-cup sizes, with $15 off with code PODCAST15. Hysteria — hosted by Erin Ryan and Alyssa Mastromonaco — is cross-promoted as sharp, humorous political analysis from a women's perspective.
-
Tommy frames the interview with Musk's own words: his demand that critics 'name one person' who died, his claim that USAID is responsible for COVID and the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and his dismissal of humanitarian aid as fraud. Kristof responds with names and specifics from his reporting in South Sudan, Liberia, and Uganda. Peter Dande and Evan Anzu — HIV-positive children kept alive by PEPFAR who died after health workers connecting them to the system were fired. Yama Freeman, a mother who hemorrhaged to death in a hammock carried by village men because DOGE cut the diesel for ambulances the US had already provided. Jabea, a fourth-grade girl ranked third in her class who died of malaria after DOGE eliminated bed nets, fired community health workers, stripped anti-malaria medicine from clinics, and cut ambulance fuel — a sequential cascade of failures each individually preventable for trivial sums. Kristof also describes how the DRC Ebola outbreak — 1,200+ cases, 300+ deaths — grew unchecked because USAID's early-warning networks were defunded. He is precise about limitations: mortality data collection was itself decimated by the cuts, making exact numbers impossible. But he argues the order of magnitude — hundreds of thousands of deaths per year — is fundamentally right.
-
Tommy pushes Kristof on the large-scale mortality estimates. Kristof validates the methodology while flagging its limitation: USAID cuts also destroyed the data collection systems that would measure their own impact, and deaths are cumulative — people with HIV don't die immediately when ARVs stop, but their vulnerability compounds over months. He predicts 2026 mortality from the cuts will exceed 2025's toll. On rebuilding, Kristof argues for evidence-based programs with randomized controlled trials behind them, acknowledging that both parties have funded ideological pet projects — Democratic women's empowerment programs without evidence, Republican abstinence-only HIV programs — rather than proven interventions. He doesn't think moving USAID to State was necessarily fatal if it has internal support and funding. He identifies Sudan as the world's worst humanitarian crisis currently receiving almost no attention. He closes on the Israeli prison sexual violence investigation: the story started with a single Palestinian peace activist's account two years ago, grew into 14 independent corroborating testimonies from people unaware of each other, all describing assault by guards, settlers, and Shin Bet. Netanyahu called it 'one of the worst blood libelsl ever to appear in the modern press.' Kristof says the correct response would be to let the Red Cross into the prison system — something that hasn't happened.
-
Tommy wraps the Kristof interview with gratitude for the reporter's personal risk in traveling to conflict zones and urges listeners not to let Musk escape accountability for the USAID destruction. He reminds listeners to subscribe at crooked.com/friends for ad-free episodes and bonus content. Production credits acknowledge producers Ilona Minkowski, Michael Goldsmith, and Nenisha Banerjee, plus the broader team. The episode closes with repeat cross-promotions for Hysteria and a Shopify small-business ad featuring Yowie founder Shannon Maldonado, plus an OnDeck small-business lending spot.
- TPS (Temporary Protected Status)
- A US immigration status established in 1990 that allows nationals of designated countries experiencing ongoing crises — wars, natural disasters — to live and work legally in the US.
- PEPFAR
- The President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, launched by President George W. Bush in 2003; the US program credited with saving 26 million lives by funding HIV/AIDS treatment globally.
- ARVs (antiretrovirals)
- Antiretroviral medications that suppress HIV in the body, preventing AIDS; people living with HIV must take them continuously or the virus can rebound and become fatal.
- DART team
- Disaster Assistance Response Team — a rapid-deployment unit of specialists funded by USAID that conducts search-and-rescue and delivers emergency aid after major disasters abroad.
- MOU (Memorandum of Understanding)
- A non-binding agreement between parties that outlines intended actions or commitments; used here to describe the US-Iran ceasefire framework.
- IRGC
- Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps — Iran's elite paramilitary and ideological military force, separate from the conventional armed forces, that controls key strategic assets including the Strait of Hormuz.
- Strait of Hormuz
- A narrow waterway between Iran and Oman through which roughly 20% of the world's oil supply passes; control of it is a central strategic objective in the US-Iran conflict described in this episode.
- Afrikaner
- White South Africans descended primarily from Dutch settlers; the Trump administration controversially extended refugee status to Afrikaners claiming persecution while denying it to Haitians and Syrians.
- Dred Scott decision
- An 1857 Supreme Court ruling that Black Americans, including freed slaves, could never be US citizens; overturned by the 14th Amendment, which Trump's executive order attempted to reinterpret.
- Fig leaf
- A token gesture that conceals an embarrassing or unresolved reality; used by Ben Rhodes to describe the Israel-Lebanon peace deal as diplomatic cover for the US-Iran MOU rather than a genuine solution.
- No-bid contract
- A government contract awarded without a competitive bidding process; used here to describe how Trump-connected companies may be getting preferential Pentagon deals.
- Randomized controlled trial (RCT)
- A rigorous scientific study design where participants are randomly assigned to treatment or control groups; Kristof cites RCT evidence as the standard foreign aid programs should meet.
- Contact tracing
- The public health practice of identifying and monitoring people who may have been exposed to an infectious disease, critical for containing outbreaks like Ebola.
- Levered / leveraged
- Describes investments made using borrowed money to amplify potential gains; Tommy Vietor warns that leveraged market positions create significant systemic risk.
- Status quo ante
- Latin for 'the state of things before'; used by Ben Rhodes to describe Iran restoring its pre-war military capabilities after US strikes.
- Oligarch
- A member of a small group that controls enormous wealth and political power, often in post-Soviet states; used to draw parallels between Kazakhstani elites and Trump-era family corruption.
- Gaslighting
- A form of psychological manipulation in which someone causes another to question their perception of reality; used to describe Musk's denial that USAID cuts caused any deaths.
- Blood libel
- A historically antisemitic accusation; the Israeli government provocatively applied the term to Nicholas Kristof's investigative reporting on Israeli prison sexual violence.
- Hegemonic
- Relating to dominance or leadership by one country or group over others; implicitly used in discussions of US and Iranian competition for influence over the Strait of Hormuz.
- Pyramid scheme
- A fraudulent investment model where returns for earlier participants are paid using money from new entrants rather than genuine profit; Ben Rhodes uses it to describe speculative AI-driven market dynamics.
Chapter 4 · 07:00
Israel-Lebanon 14-Point Peace Agreement
Tommy walks through the mechanics of the 14-point deal: phased Lebanese Armed Forces takeover of pilot zones, Lebanon's pledge to reject Hezbollah's security role, and a framework for eventual IDF withdrawal without any specified timeline. Skepticism is immediate and comes from all sides. Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir called it a 'historic mistake.' Defense Minister Katz said Israel won't withdraw a millimeter until Hezbollah disarms. Lebanese officials with and without Hezbollah ties called it a humiliation that could trigger civil war or legitimize a long occupation. Ben Rhodes frames the deal bluntly: you cannot disarm Hezbollah with an agreement Hezbollah didn't sign. The real purpose, he argues, is face-saving diplomacy to allow the US-Iran MOU to move forward — not a genuine solution to a conflict that has killed at least 4,000 Lebanese civilians.
Claims made here
At least 4,000 people have died in Lebanon since the March 2nd war started between Israel and Hezbollah.
A peace deal that excludes the central armed party is not a peace deal. Ben Rhodes and Tommy Vietor break down why the Israel-Lebanon 14-point agreement, which Hezbollah never signed and explicitly rejects, is more fig leaf than solution — a diplomatic veneer designed to keep the US-Iran MOU alive rather than resolve the conflict.
Israel and Lebanon signed a 14-point peace agreement in Washington aimed at transferring security control to Lebanese forces, but Hezbollah — the central party — was excluded from negotiations.
At least 4,000 people have died in Lebanon since the war restarted on March 2nd, illustrating the human cost of the conflict's continuation despite ceasefire efforts.
Chapter 5 · 12:55
US-Iran Ceasefire: Airstrikes, Doha Talks, and Strait Control
Tommy details the week's timeline: Iran fires an attack drone at a tanker for taking the 'wrong' route through the Strait; the US retaliates by hitting Iranian missile and drone sites; Iran attacks another tanker; the US strikes again; Trump threatens on Truth Social that 'the Islamic Republic of Iran will no longer exist'; the IRGC fires at US bases in Bahrain and Kuwait, killing a Qatari national; then Witkoff and Kushner head to Doha for talks Iran says they only attend to discuss frozen assets. Ben Rhodes delivers the strategic verdict: Iran has secured something more valuable than nuclear deterrence — control of 20% of the world's energy supply, with a future fee-collection model in mind. Jennifer Griffin's Fox News reporting, commended by Rhodes for its quality, confirms the US had to restrike because Iran already rebuilt its missile defenses since the ceasefire — undermining any claim of lasting military victory. Tommy adds that tanker traffic is still only 70% of pre-war levels and the global oil cost to consumers was likely $60-70 billion in extra spending.
Claims made here
Iran controls approximately 20% of the world's energy supply through the Strait of Hormuz.
Iran reconstituted its air defenses and missile systems along the Strait of Hormuz after the ceasefire, requiring the US to strike them again.
China cut oil imports by about 3 million barrels per day, which helped prevent oil prices from reaching predicted catastrophic levels.
Tanker traffic through the Strait of Hormuz recovered to only about 70% of pre-war levels following the US-Iran ceasefire, according to Kpler data.
Iran's real strategic prize from the US-Iran conflict isn't sanctions relief or even a nuclear program — it's permanent control of the Strait of Hormuz. Ben Rhodes argues that by establishing the right to regulate ship traffic and eventually charge fees, Iran has secured a revenue stream worth more than any temporary deal.
Trump's social media posts threatening to end Iran as a civilization aren't diplomatic signals — they're content for his most credulous supporters. Ben Rhodes argues Iran has correctly decoded this, which is why they keep testing the ceasefire: they know the posts are performance, not policy.
Energy experts predicted $150-per-barrel oil after the US-Iran war. They were wrong. Tommy Vietor walks through the real reasons: a weaker Chinese economy cutting 3 million barrels per day of demand, Trump bullying futures markets, countries tapping strategic reserves faster than expected, and tankers willing to run the gauntlet through the Strait.
Tanker traffic through the Strait of Hormuz recovered to only about 70% of pre-war levels, according to Kpler data, leaving global energy supply still vulnerable.
Chapter 7 · 25:38
Kazakhstan Corruption: Trump Sons, Lutnick Kids, and $1.6B in Federal Financing
Tommy lays out the anatomy of the Kazakhstan deal: a company called Kaz Resources gets access to the world's largest untapped tungsten reserve after Trump-level diplomatic pressure on Kazakhstan's president; a Trump sons-affiliated firm called Dominari Securities takes a 20% stake; Howard Lutnick's kids at Cantor Fitzgerald raise $210M and pocket millions in fees; and the administration then approves $1.6B in federal financing for the project. The Times found this is not an isolated scandal — the Trump and Lutnick families have financial ties to at least 14 similar mining deals. Ben Rhodes connects the dots historically, tracing the template back to post-Soviet oligarchic capitalism in Central Asia, where political power and natural resources were bundled into family business from day one. He notes Trump literally hosted a Central Asian summit — held while Crooked Con was in the same hotel — that now reads as a deal-structuring event. The parallel corruption of Donald Trump Jr.'s Vulcan Elements investment, which 10x'd after a $600M Pentagon injection, confirms the pattern. Rhodes names it directly: this is the Epstein class running America's defense supply chain.
Claims made here
The Trump administration preliminarily approved $1.6 billion in federal financing for a Kazakhstan tungsten mining project in which Trump sons and the Lutnick family hold financial stakes.
The Trump and Lutnick families have financial ties to at least 14 companies actively working with the federal government on critical mining deals.
Donald Trump Jr.'s VC firm invested in Vulcan Elements at a $200M valuation; after a $600M Pentagon investment, the company's valuation rose to approximately $2 billion.
Howard Lutnick made a $25 million donation to the Trump Presidential Library after his children created bad headlines from questionable business activities.
The Kazakhstan tungsten story isn't a one-off scandal — it's the template. Trump pressures Kazakhstan to open the world's largest untapped tungsten reserve to a US company; Trump sons' firm takes a 20% stake; Lutnick's kids raise $210M in fees; the Trump administration then approves $1.6B in federal financing for the project. The New York Times found at least 14 similar deals.
The Trump administration preliminarily approved $1.6 billion in federal financing for a Kazakhstan tungsten mining project that benefits the Trump and Lutnick families financially.
The Trump and Lutnick families have financial ties to at least 14 companies actively working with the federal government on critical mining deals, per the New York Times.
Ben Rhodes traces the Kazakhstan corruption story back to its roots in post-Soviet oligarchic capitalism, where resources were gifted to whoever had political power. Fast-forward to 2025: the Trump and Lutnick families are doing the same thing — using the Pentagon's trillion-dollar budget as a piggy bank, cutting no-bid deals with Central Asian autocrats for minerals essential to US military hardware.
Donald Trump Jr.'s VC firm took a stake in Vulcan Elements at a $200M valuation; after a $600M Pentagon injection, the company's valuation rose to $2 billion — a 10x return.
Chapter 8 · 34:57
Supreme Court Rulings: Birthright Citizenship and TPS for Haitians and Syrians
Tommy frames the birthright ruling as good news that shouldn't require celebration — the plain text of the 14th Amendment is not ambiguous — but notes the effective margin was 5-4 because Kavanaugh agreed with the outcome while declining to join the majority opinion, signaling a future path to reversal. The TPS ruling is less ambiguous as good news: 350,000 Haitians are being sent back to a country the State Department rates 'do not travel,' where gangs control major territory and half the population faces acute hunger, while white South Afrikaners receive welcome bags full of revisionist history books. Ben Rhodes invokes Frederick Douglass to skewer conservative originalists for ignoring the 14th Amendment's actual authors, who clearly intended universal birthright citizenship. He and Tommy both call the TPS ruling what it is: straightforwardly racist, constitutionally rationalized. Rhodes adds that Venezuelan TPS holders who supported Republican policies because of Maduro opposition have now been told exactly what the party thinks of them.
Claims made here
The Supreme Court upheld birthright citizenship in a 6-3 ruling, but Justice Kavanaugh agreed with the result while declining to join the majority opinion.
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to give DHS authority to remove Temporary Protected Status from 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians.
The State Department lists Haiti as a 'do not travel' destination and the World Food Program says half the Haitian population faces acute hunger.
The Supreme Court upheld birthright citizenship — but barely. The 6-3 ruling is more like 5-4 because Kavanaugh agreed with the outcome but not the majority opinion and has signaled a path to eliminating it later. Tommy and Ben note the absurdity of celebrating a ruling that simply upheld the plain text of the 14th Amendment.
The Supreme Court upheld birthright citizenship 6-3, though effectively 5-4 since Kavanaugh agreed with the result but not the majority opinion, with Trump having tried to end it via executive order.
The Supreme Court's 6-3 ruling stripping Temporary Protected Status from 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians — while white South Africans get refugee welcome bags — is not a close legal question. Ben Rhodes and Tommy Vietor argue the racial double standard is self-evident and that the Court's blessing of Stephen Miller's immigration agenda is a lasting stain.
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to allow DHS to remove Temporary Protected Status from 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians, upending the lives of hundreds of thousands.
Chapter 9 · 43:10
Venezuela Earthquake: Humanitarian Crisis and Political Fallout
Tommy recaps the scale of the disaster: 1,700+ casualties, 50,000 missing, and a humanitarian response that looks nothing like the 17,000 US military personnel mobilized for Haiti in 2010. The Trump administration pledged $300 million and 300+ search-and-rescue personnel, but the context is radically worse: a healthcare infrastructure already decimated, USAID dismantled, and an international aid system hollowed out. Crowds jeered Rodriguez at disaster sites, chanting 'get out'; Venezuela's own military was conspicuously absent while citizens dug through rubble by hand. Ben Rhodes argues that the Maduro removal was never about democratic transformation — it was tribute extraction, with Trump people doing oil and real estate deals rather than building a responsive government. He draws a direct parallel to the 2010 Haiti earthquake, which killed 310,000 people and ultimately collapsed the Haitian government even with a functioning USAID. He warns that the combination of an unreformed repressive government, a shattered trust, and a gutted international response system makes Venezuela's trajectory very dangerous.
Venezuela's catastrophic earthquakes — 1,700+ dead, 50,000 missing — are testing Delcy Rodriguez's interim government in ways that expose how little changed when Maduro was ousted. The military sat by while citizens dug through rubble with their hands. Ben Rhodes argues the Trump administration's 'success' in Venezuela was always just tribute extraction, not real political change.
A pair of catastrophic earthquakes in Venezuela produced at least 1,700 known casualties and left 50,000 people missing, severely testing the interim government.
Chapter 10 · 51:35
Sponsor: Incogni & Ridge Wallet
Incogni is pitched as an automated data broker opt-out service that continuously monitors and removes personal data, independently verified by Deloitte; listeners get 60% off an annual plan with code PSTW at incogni.com/PSTW with a 30-day money-back guarantee. Ridge follows with a pitch for its slim aluminum, titanium, and carbon fiber wallets — holding up to 12 cards, with a tracker card, lifetime warranty, and 10% off with code PSTW at ridge.com.
Claims made here
France's health ministry recorded more than 1,000 unexpected deaths, including 74 drownings, during the most recent European heat wave.
France is having an identity crisis over air conditioning while people drown trying to escape the heat. 1,000+ extra deaths. Hospitals with 95-degree wards. A maternity unit asking patients to bring fans from home. Tommy Vietor documents the maddening debate, and Ben Rhodes delivers the political verdict: if the left opposes AC in public buildings, Marine Le Pen will ride this straight to the Élysée.
France's health ministry recorded more than 1,000 unexpected deaths, including 74 drownings, during the latest European heat dome, fueling the debate over air conditioning.
Chapter 11 · 53:00
France's Air Conditioning Culture War and the European Heat Wave
Tommy lays out the cultural stakes first: only 25% of French households have AC, and the arguments against expanding it range from environmental (it heats cities and uses energy) to identity-based (France will lose its outdoor culture). Then the political circus: Marine Le Pen is running on 'AC for All' while Jean-Luc Mélenchon opposes public building cooling and Macron's ecological minister says she's 'horrified' by AC proposals. The absurdity peaks when Tommy reports a Parisian hospital where 27 of 30 wards had no AC and temperatures reached 95 degrees, with staff telling patients to bring fans to the maternity ward. A French influencer video showing food being cooked on a window ledge in the sun illustrates just how hot it actually is. Ben Rhodes, who spent a week in 100-degree London without any AC and watched a heat conference get canceled because of the heat, frames the political lesson clearly: use the heat to argue for a clean energy transition, but do not oppose air conditioning in public buildings. Workers riding un-air-conditioned buses need relief now. The left will hand Marine Le Pen the Élysée if they choose this hill.
Claims made here
In 2025, approximately 95% of energy generated in mainland France was low carbon, mostly nuclear plus renewables.
Only about 25% of French households have air conditioning, leaving most of the population vulnerable to the record-breaking European heat waves.
Ben Rhodes was in London when it hit 100 degrees Fahrenheit — and podcasted through it in his un-air-conditioned Airbnb. He describes the genuine danger of a city where no bus, no train, no restaurant, no workplace offers any relief from the heat. The Tube stopped in a tunnel. A conference on extreme heat was canceled due to extreme heat.
Chapter 12 · 1:00:40
World Cup 2026: The Agony of Defeats
Tommy rattles through the elimination highlights: Germany beaten by Paraguay on penalties; the Netherlands eliminated by Morocco also on penalties in a game Ben slept through until 5 AM Amsterdam time when the city's collective anxiety woke him up; Uruguay eliminated with their soccer federation canceling the charter flight home as punishment; and South Korea's catastrophic exit — needing only a draw against lower-ranked South Africa and losing — that has prompted a presidential investigation and airport jeering. Ben describes wandering around Amsterdam the night before the Dutch game, seeing boats with big screen TVs and fully stocked bars, then waking at 5 AM to every penalty kick being accompanied by citywide honking and shouting. When the Netherlands lost, he heard 'a lot of drunk people making very unpleasant noises' and refused to leave his hotel. He also reveals he's in Amsterdam on vacation after his book tour, which was this episode's teased Easter egg. Both hosts praise Morocco's run as part of a broader African teams story and a meaningful anti-colonial sporting narrative.
Ben Rhodes woke up at 5 AM in Amsterdam to the sounds of the city reacting to each Dutch penalty kick — and then to the sound of drunk people making 'very unpleasant noises' after Morocco knocked them out. Tommy adds that South Korea's president has ordered an investigation into the team's performance. The World Cup is delivering more drama off the pitch than on.
Chapter 14 · 1:11:30
Nicholas Kristof Interview: Elon Musk's USAID Lies
Tommy frames the interview with Musk's own words: his demand that critics 'name one person' who died, his claim that USAID is responsible for COVID and the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and his dismissal of humanitarian aid as fraud. Kristof responds with names and specifics from his reporting in South Sudan, Liberia, and Uganda. Peter Dande and Evan Anzu — HIV-positive children kept alive by PEPFAR who died after health workers connecting them to the system were fired. Yama Freeman, a mother who hemorrhaged to death in a hammock carried by village men because DOGE cut the diesel for ambulances the US had already provided. Jabea, a fourth-grade girl ranked third in her class who died of malaria after DOGE eliminated bed nets, fired community health workers, stripped anti-malaria medicine from clinics, and cut ambulance fuel — a sequential cascade of failures each individually preventable for trivial sums. Kristof also describes how the DRC Ebola outbreak — 1,200+ cases, 300+ deaths — grew unchecked because USAID's early-warning networks were defunded. He is precise about limitations: mortality data collection was itself decimated by the cuts, making exact numbers impossible. But he argues the order of magnitude — hundreds of thousands of deaths per year — is fundamentally right.
Claims made here
Approximately 83% of USAID programs were canceled and 94% of staff were laid off as a result of DOGE's dismantling of the agency.
PEPFAR, started by President Bush in 2003, has saved 26 million lives through HIV/AIDS treatment globally.
The Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo produced over 1,200 cases and more than 300 deaths, worsened by the defunding of USAID's early-warning health networks in the region.
Approximately 83% of USAID programs were canceled and 94% of staff were laid off as a result of Elon Musk and DOGE's destruction of the agency.
Elon Musk demanded that critics name a single person who died because of DOGE's USAID cuts. Nicholas Kristof names them: Peter Dande, Evan Anzu, HIV-positive children who died after health workers were fired. Yama Freeman, who bled to death because DOGE cut ambulance diesel. Jabea, a 4th-grade girl ranked third in her class who died of malaria after cuts eliminated bed nets, health workers, medicine, and fuel in a cascade of failure.
The PEPFAR program started by President Bush in 2003 has saved 26 million lives, and disruption to it by DOGE funding freezes has caused preventable deaths in children.
The Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo has produced over 1,200 cases and more than 300 deaths, worsened by the dismantling of USAID's early-warning networks.
Chapter 15 · 1:21:10
Nicholas Kristof: Death Toll Projections, Rebuilding USAID, and Israeli Prison Violence
Tommy pushes Kristof on the large-scale mortality estimates. Kristof validates the methodology while flagging its limitation: USAID cuts also destroyed the data collection systems that would measure their own impact, and deaths are cumulative — people with HIV don't die immediately when ARVs stop, but their vulnerability compounds over months. He predicts 2026 mortality from the cuts will exceed 2025's toll. On rebuilding, Kristof argues for evidence-based programs with randomized controlled trials behind them, acknowledging that both parties have funded ideological pet projects — Democratic women's empowerment programs without evidence, Republican abstinence-only HIV programs — rather than proven interventions. He doesn't think moving USAID to State was necessarily fatal if it has internal support and funding. He identifies Sudan as the world's worst humanitarian crisis currently receiving almost no attention. He closes on the Israeli prison sexual violence investigation: the story started with a single Palestinian peace activist's account two years ago, grew into 14 independent corroborating testimonies from people unaware of each other, all describing assault by guards, settlers, and Shin Bet. Netanyahu called it 'one of the worst blood libelsl ever to appear in the modern press.' Kristof says the correct response would be to let the Red Cross into the prison system — something that hasn't happened.
Claims made here
A Boston University research tracker estimated that over 780,000 people have died as a result of USAID cuts.
The Lancet published a study estimating that 9.4 million additional deaths could occur by 2030 as a result of USAID cuts.
Americans believe approximately 20% of the federal budget goes to foreign assistance; in reality, it is about 1% of the budget, or $0.22 of every $100 of national income.
The Lancet estimates 9.4 million additional deaths by 2030 from USAID cuts. A Boston University tracker puts current deaths above 780,000. Nicholas Kristof explains why these numbers are probably right in order of magnitude: the cuts also destroyed data collection systems, deaths are cumulative and lagged, and malnutrition combined with disease multiplies fatality rates over time.
A Lancet study estimated that 9.4 million additional deaths could occur by 2030 as a result of USAID cuts, while a Boston University tracker puts current deaths above 780,000.
Rebuilding USAID doesn't require recreating it exactly as it was. Kristof argues the key is evidence-based programs with randomized controlled trials behind them — cutting both Democratic 'touchy-feely' empowerment programs without evidence and Republican abstinence-only HIV programs. Keep it at State if needed, but fund it and focus it on the places that need it most.
Nicholas Kristof describes how his investigation into Israeli prison sexual violence started with a single account from a Palestinian peace activist two years ago and grew into 14 independent, corroborating accounts of rape and assault by prison guards, settlers, and Shin Bet agents. Netanyahu called it a 'blood libel.' Kristof says the right response would be to let the Red Cross in.
No indexed bits in this chapter.
Show stoppers
Snapshots ()
Key Quotes ()
This episode
Cast
-
US President whose family members benefit financially from mining deals linked to federal government contracts, and whose administration dismantled USAID while escalating conflict with Iran.
-
Criticized throughout for claiming USAID cuts killed nobody, while reporters documented preventable deaths in Africa caused by DOGE's dismantling of the agency.
-
New York Times columnist who reported from South Sudan, Uganda, and Liberia on children dying as a result of USAID cuts, directly rebutting Elon Musk's denials.
-
US Commerce Secretary whose children, now running Cantor Fitzgerald, helped raise $210M for a Kazakhstan tungsten deal that also benefits the Trump sons.
-
Israeli Prime Minister whose government expressed skepticism about the Lebanon deal and threatened legal action against Nicholas Kristof over his reporting on Israeli prison sexual violence.
-
French far-right National Rally leader running on a platform of 'air conditioning for all' amid the European heat wave, which Tommy and Ben warn could propel her to the presidency.
-
The US foreign aid agency dismantled by Elon Musk and DOGE, with 83% of programs canceled and 94% of staff laid off, causing widespread preventable deaths globally.
-
The Department of Government Efficiency led by Elon Musk that dismantled USAID, cutting 83% of programs and 94% of staff, causing widespread preventable deaths.
-
The Lebanese militant group excluded from the 14-point Washington peace agreement between Israel and Lebanon, making the deal's implementation deeply uncertain.
-
Upheld birthright citizenship 6-3 and ruled 6-3 to allow removal of TPS from 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians, with broad national security and human rights implications.
-
Investment bank run by Howard Lutnick's children while their father serves as Commerce Secretary; helped raise over $210M for the Kazakhstan tungsten mining deal.
-
President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief, started by President Bush in 2003, which has saved 26 million lives but was disrupted by DOGE's funding freezes, causing preventable deaths.
-
Company in which Donald Trump Jr.'s VC firm took a stake at a $200M valuation; valuation rose to $2B after a $600M Pentagon investment injection.
-
Country engaged in an ongoing fragile ceasefire with the US, continuing to fire on tankers and reposition military assets near the Strait of Hormuz.
-
Country that signed a 14-point peace agreement with Israel in Washington, but faces deep skepticism about implementation given Hezbollah's exclusion from the deal.
-
Strategic waterway through which 20% of the world's oil passes; Iran's control over it is described as its primary strategic objective in the US-Iran conflict.
-
Country struck by catastrophic earthquakes killing 1,700+ with 50,000 missing, severely testing the interim government installed after Trump-backed removal of Nicolás Maduro.
-
Central Asian country at the center of a corruption story involving Trump sons, Lutnick kids, and $1.6B in federal financing for a tungsten mining deal.
-
Country experiencing a worsening Ebola outbreak with 1,200+ cases and 300+ deaths, exacerbated by USAID's dismantling of early-warning health networks.
-
National team that eliminated the Netherlands in the World Cup on penalty kicks, celebrated as part of a broader trend of African teams outperforming expectations in the tournament.
Stats
This episode
Claims & Sources
Factual claims made this episode, and whether a source was named.
The 14-point Israel-Lebanon peace agreement does not include the word 'withdraw' and does not specify a timeframe for Israeli withdrawal.
At least 4,000 people have died in Lebanon since the March 2nd war started between Israel and Hezbollah.
Tanker traffic through the Strait of Hormuz recovered to only about 70% of pre-war levels following the US-Iran ceasefire, according to Kpler data.
Iran controls approximately 20% of the world's energy supply through the Strait of Hormuz.
Iran reconstituted its air defenses and missile systems along the Strait of Hormuz after the ceasefire, requiring the US to strike them again.
China cut oil imports by about 3 million barrels per day, which helped prevent oil prices from reaching predicted catastrophic levels.
The Trump administration preliminarily approved $1.6 billion in federal financing for a Kazakhstan tungsten mining project in which Trump sons and the Lutnick family hold financial stakes.
The Trump and Lutnick families have financial ties to at least 14 companies actively working with the federal government on critical mining deals.
Donald Trump Jr.'s VC firm invested in Vulcan Elements at a $200M valuation; after a $600M Pentagon investment, the company's valuation rose to approximately $2 billion.
Howard Lutnick made a $25 million donation to the Trump Presidential Library after his children created bad headlines from questionable business activities.
The Supreme Court upheld birthright citizenship in a 6-3 ruling, but Justice Kavanaugh agreed with the result while declining to join the majority opinion.
The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 to give DHS authority to remove Temporary Protected Status from 350,000 Haitians and 6,000 Syrians.
The State Department lists Haiti as a 'do not travel' destination and the World Food Program says half the Haitian population faces acute hunger.
Approximately 83% of USAID programs were canceled and 94% of staff were laid off as a result of DOGE's dismantling of the agency.
PEPFAR, started by President Bush in 2003, has saved 26 million lives through HIV/AIDS treatment globally.
A Boston University research tracker estimated that over 780,000 people have died as a result of USAID cuts.
The Lancet published a study estimating that 9.4 million additional deaths could occur by 2030 as a result of USAID cuts.
Americans believe approximately 20% of the federal budget goes to foreign assistance; in reality, it is about 1% of the budget, or $0.22 of every $100 of national income.
The Ebola outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo produced over 1,200 cases and more than 300 deaths, worsened by the defunding of USAID's early-warning health networks in the region.
France's health ministry recorded more than 1,000 unexpected deaths, including 74 drownings, during the most recent European heat wave.
In 2025, approximately 95% of energy generated in mainland France was low carbon, mostly nuclear plus renewables.