Quote · TED Talks Daily
Confessions of an accidental killer | Gregg Ward
Where this was said
Bad Advice and the Problem With Self-Forgiveness
At 10:33 · chapter starts 9:42
Ward maps the landscape of bad advice with mordant clarity. [1] — Gregg Ward "The most common advice after causing irreversible harm is 'forgive yourself.' Ward rejects this entirely. To him, self-forgiveness is indis…" 10:00 At the funeral, someone told him God wanted Michelle in heaven. He understood the intent; he found it maddening. But the advice he kept receiving — over and over — was to forgive himself. To Ward, that instruction is morally incoherent. Self-forgiveness, as he understands it, is a mechanism for feeling better about yourself by quietly releasing yourself from responsibility. He was wholly responsible for what happened that night. He always will be. Forgiving himself is 'off the table.' What he needed, and couldn't find in the standard self-help toolkit, was not absolution but a framework: how do you move forward in a positive way without either punishing yourself indefinitely or pretending it didn't matter? The distinction he draws — between accountability and self-punishment — is the hinge on which the rest of the talk turns.
Ward observes that most people don't confront their regrets until they're dying, and by then it's usually too late to make amends.
The most common advice after causing irreversible harm is 'forgive yourself.' Ward rejects this entirely. To him, self-forgiveness is indistinguishable from making excuses — a way to feel better at the cost of genuine accountability. He was wholly responsible. He always will be. Moving forward is not the same as letting yourself off the hook.
Ward argues that forgiving yourself can function as making an excuse or letting yourself off the hook, and rejects it as a valid response to serious regret.
Right after the accident, a friend asked Ward: 'What have you learned? And what are you going to do about it?' It was harsh. Ward wasn't ready. But those two questions became the axis on which his entire philosophy of regret eventually turned — from passive suffering to purposeful action.
