Maggie Haberman: A Gross and Messy White House
Trump has declared a "pardon radius" around the Oval Office and tells aides they can all expect clemency — creating a White House where breaking the law feels consequence-free.
The Bulwark Podcast
Maggie Haberman: A Gross and Messy White House
Trump has declared a "pardon radius" around the Oval Office and tells aides they can all expect clemency — creating a White House where breaking the law feels consequence-free.
TL;DR
Maggie Haberman joins Tim Miller to discuss her new book "Regime Change," co-authored with Jonathan Swan, revealing how Trump has transformed the U.S. presidency into something unrecognizable. Key revelations include Trump walking around saying "I'm immune," a pardon radius around the Oval Office, Marco Rubio personally brokering the CECOT prison deal with Bukele [1] — Maggie Haberman "Rubio sat with El Salvador's Bukele in his palace and personally hashed out the CECOT arrangement, which was supposed to target only verifi…" 14:15 , Elon Musk acting as a de facto co-president from a video-game-filled office suite [2] — Maggie Haberman "Musk rejected his cramped West Wing office and set up shop in the grand Secretary of War suites in the EEOB, playing video games late into …" 10:25 , and Trump's bedroom littered with ice cream cartons and Starburst wrappers [3] — Maggie Haberman "Trump's White House bedroom featured potato chip bags, ice cream cartons, Starburst wrappers, a carpeted bathroom, and bankers boxes stacke…" 40:35 . Cameron Kasky then breaks down the DSA's primary surge and what's driving it beyond just Gaza. The single most actionable takeaway: Trump's loss in 2020 made him far more powerful than a second consecutive term would have.
Maggie Haberman and Cameron Kasky join Tim Miller to discuss Trump's imperial presidency and the DSA's primary surge. Haberman reveals details from her new book 'Regime Change' including Trump's pardon plans, Musk's co-presidency, Rubio's CECOT deal, and Trump's personal habits. Kasky reports from the ground on progressive primary campaigns in Maine and Michigan.
-
The episode opens with back-to-back pre-roll advertisements. First, McDonald's promotes its six new summer drinks — Refreshers with popping boba and crafted sodas including a Sprite Berry Blast with cold foam. Then Novo Nordisk runs a branded Ozempic ad reminding listeners that only they make FDA-approved Ozempic semaglutide, distinguishing it from other GLP-1 medications. Neither ad contains editorial content relevant to the episode.
-
Tim Miller opens the Bulwark Podcast, previewing a double-header episode. He introduces Cameron Kasky — described with characteristic Miller wit as 'the podcast's favorite Gen Z bisexual quasi-communist' — for the second segment on the DSA's primary performance. But first, he welcomes Maggie Haberman, New York Times White House correspondent and co-author with Jonathan Swan of the new book 'Regime Change: Inside the Imperial Presidency of Donald Trump.' Miller's opening question is disarmingly blunt: he admits he doesn't understand why people want to relive Trump's first year in long-form prose.
-
Haberman pushes back on Miller's skepticism, explaining that 'Regime Change' is not nostalgic re-reporting but an attempt to understand something genuinely new. Unlike the first term — where half the White House viewed Trump as dangerous and was actively leaking — the current administration is staffed by true believers who want Trump's agenda to succeed. The book nearly killed Haberman and Swan to report, she says, because the sources are tight-knit and secrets are kept. The core thesis: Trump has expanded and transformed the U.S. presidency to a degree not seen in our lifetimes, and the title 'Regime Change' reflects the authors' belief that America is experiencing a domestic version of the phenomenon usually reserved for foreign nations.
-
Haberman lays out the book's central counterintuitive premise: Trump's 2020 defeat was actually the foundation of his current power. Had he won, he would have owned post-pandemic inflation and the chaotic Afghanistan withdrawal — both deeply damaging political liabilities. Instead, he became a mythic figure within his party, enduring criminal indictments, a conviction, civil suits, and two assassination attempts. The resulting congressional Republican dynamic is one of both awe and fear, enabling Trump to maintain what he and his team openly call an 'iron fist.' His ban from Twitter, far from being a political setback, helped insulate him — his most caustic posts went to Truth Social, reaching far fewer people. The cumulative effect is a president who could never have wielded this much power with two consecutive terms.
-
The conversation moves to one of the book's most vivid early scenes: Trump wanted to announce sweeping J6 pardons in his inaugural address. An aide warned that Democrats would walk out on camera, and Trump relented — his last concession to decorum. Hours later he pardoned roughly 1,500 people anyway, including those who attacked police officers. The immunity discussion then expands to the Supreme Court's presidential immunity ruling, which Trump has internalized as a simple, all-encompassing phrase: 'I'm immune.' Haberman reveals that Trump has repeatedly told associates he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within 200 to 250 feet of the Oval Office — what she calls a 'pardon radius.' Several people who have spoken to Haberman and Swan are personally banking on receiving one. It creates, she notes, 'a certain mindset.'
-
Haberman turns to one of the most astonishing periods in the book: the Musk co-presidency. Musk rejected his cramped West Wing 'hovel' and relocated to the magnificent Secretary of War suites in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, which he made his own with large video game screens. According to Haberman's reporting, he would call Trump late at night to propose cutting government entities — including, in one instance, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. His unilateral decisions often surprised Trump's own official staff. He didn't always align with Stephen Miller or Russell Vought on methods, creating internal friction. His most aggressive target was USAID — a congressionally established agency — which he effectively dismantled, leaving Marco Rubio to clean up the mess. The Musk era, Haberman notes, feels like ancient history now, but it dominated the first several months of the presidency and had lasting consequences.
-
Tim Miller zeroes in on what he considers one of the most underreported revelations in the book: Rubio sitting with Bukele in his palace and personally hashing out the CECOT arrangement. The original pitch was a 'safe third' style agreement, but Bukele offered up CECOT as a destination for deportees — supposedly the most dangerous gang members, each rigorously vetted. The vetting, as events proved, was fiction: innocent people were sent, including Venezuelans with explicit no-deportation orders to El Salvador. One such case became a weeks-long political controversy for the administration. Haberman argues the Rubio-Bukele scene is emblematic of what this administration actually looks like — and that the desire to cast Rubio as a grown-up or a John Kelly figure is simply not supported by anything in the reporting.
-
Having personally observed Rubio in the White House's Upper Press area, Haberman reports that he is constantly in and out of Caroline Levitt's office and 'looks like he is having the time of his life.' This contrasts sharply with the first term's reluctant adults — John Kelly and Jim Mattis, both of whom considered Trump dangerous and found his worldview detestable. Rubio, by contrast, rarely travels internationally despite being Secretary of State because he believes he needs to be physically near Trump. And the reason for that, Haberman explains, is that the entire government is run by six to eight people depending on the issue. If you're not in the room with Trump, you have no idea what is happening at the State Department, the Pentagon, or the CIA.
-
Miller delivers a characteristically spirited membership pitch, arguing that the left and center should not cede July 4th patriotism to Trump and MAGA. 'We're here, we're queer, we're Americans, we love it,' he declares, offering a full Bulwark membership for $86 a year — 14% off — for the July 4th week only at thebulwark.com/july4. A Nordstrom Rack advertisement follows, promoting up to 60% off brands like Rag & Bone, Levi's, Adidas, and Free People through the Nordy Club loyalty program.
-
The conversation turns to one of the book's most striking chapters: how Trump's cultural campaign extended to the Smithsonian. Lindsey Halligan, an insurance lawyer who became a White House staffer, visited a Smithsonian museum, saw something she didn't like, and flagged it internally. This ultimately led to Trump demanding the firing of National Portrait Gallery director Kim Sajet, issuing executive orders about museum content, and pressuring Lonnie Bunch — the Smithsonian's first Black secretary and founder of the African American History Museum — over his institutions' exhibitions. Haberman recounts a pivotal scene at the Smithsonian Board of Regents' June 9th meeting, where a 30-something aide to Vance named Ben Moss pulled out an iPad and showed an image of Amy Sherald's trans-themed painting (based on a trans model) to the assembled regents — including Chief Justice John Roberts — and declared it was 'not what Americans want to see.' The episode, Haberman says, is unlike any directive from a White House to a cultural institution she can recall.
-
Tim Miller pivots to a more personal revelation from the book: the notes that Natalie Harp, Trump's constant information aide and 'human printer,' was leaving in his private White House spaces. Haberman describes them as raw and emotional — in one, Harp wrote 'You are all that matters to me.' The Secret Service was alarmed enough to raise concerns. Trump is open about his feelings toward Harp: she loves him on staff, he tells people, as much as his wife and children do. While the rest of his aides will eventually go make money elsewhere, he says, she will never leave him. Haberman notes that Harp — a former OAN network figure who has been with Trump since late 2021 or 2022 — was present for every single court appearance during his 2024 Manhattan trial and was one of only a handful of people in the room during Haberman and Swan's fact-checking interview with Trump.
-
Miller raises the Iran war and the surprising revelation that Trump was privately hawkish on Iran long before the conflict began. Haberman explains that Trump's view of Iran is rooted in his 1980s formative years — Jimmy Carter humiliated by the hostage crisis, Iran as the defining threat. When Netanyahu visited Mar-a-Lago after the Butler assassination attempt to make peace (Trump had been furious at Netanyahu for congratulating Biden in 2020), Trump made clear he would be far more aggressive on Iran in a second term. He was fascinated by Israel's pager attacks on Hezbollah and flush from what he saw as the clean, successful Venezuela operation — in which a foreign head of state was seized with no American casualties. He went into the Iran war expecting similar speed. His top military advisor Dan Caine warned him explicitly: munitions could be critically depleted, the Strait of Hormuz could be closed. Only JD Vance emphatically pushed back in the meetings. Trump went anyway. Now, Haberman says quietly, he wants out.
-
Miller presses Haberman on the vice president's extraordinary public allegation that the authors must have tape recordings from inside the Situation Room to have sourced certain scenes in the book. Haberman is diplomatically immovable: she will not discuss sourcing, period. She does note that the book's sourcing note describes both the volume of interviews — more than 1,000 — and the rigorous methodology for what goes in direct quotes versus paraphrase. Miller, noting this was 'a pretty serious accusation from the vice president,' doesn't push further. The exchange itself is revealing: it confirms that the book's Situation Room reporting hit a very sensitive nerve for the administration.
-
The podcast takes a sponsor break for OnDeck, a small business lending platform that offers loans up to $400,000. The ad highlights the company's A+ Better Business Bureau rating, thousands of 5-star Trustpilot reviews, and the ability to apply in minutes at ondeck.com. A disclosure notes that loans may be issued by OnDeck or Celtic Bank and that OnDeck does not lend in North Dakota.
-
Miller asks about the topic Haberman and Swan were least able to crack: Trump's physical health. She admits it freely — this was the area where their reporting most fell short, not for lack of trying. What is visible is telling enough: Trump falls asleep at public events and during his 2024 trial. His sleeping habits are strange — he was found still asleep late one morning by a trusted aide who went to the residence to check on him after he'd gone silent. He has chronic venous insufficiency causing swollen ankles, a condition that only became public when photographers noticed, and which Trump directed press secretary Caroline Levitt to address from the podium — a decision that struck many in the White House as highly unusual given his well-documented vanity. His visits to Walter Reed are increasingly frequent. And throughout, the administration has released less and less health information. Haberman's conclusion: beyond the visible facts of an 80-year-old man who 'looks 80,' she knows no more than the public does.
-
In one of the episode's most memorable passages, Haberman describes the state of Trump's private White House bedroom. When the Trumps returned, they wanted everything as they had left it — Melania hadn't arrived yet, so Trump was alone in the residence. He picked items from the center hall and distributed them between his bedroom and the Oval Office, which he was simultaneously gilding until there was 'not a square inch not covered in something gold colored.' In his own bedroom: a carpeted bathroom, ice cream cartons, potato chip bags, Starburst wrappers (not Starbucks, Haberman corrects — that was a typo in early editions). Staff monitored the silverware because pieces kept vanishing into the trash. And then there were the bankers boxes, stacked so high their removal left visible impressions in the carpet — the same 'Beautiful Mind boxes' that became central to the Mar-a-Lago documents indictment.
-
Miller offers Haberman a chance to respond to the 'why save it for the book' criticism, and she takes it seriously. The Iran war reporting, she notes, was published in the New York Times five weeks into the war — still the most comprehensive account of how Trump took the country to conflict. The habeas corpus memo reporting likewise ran in the paper after months of work to obtain the secret documents. Jonathan Swan took a 10-month leave from the Times; Haberman took five and a half. The book covers the first 14 months of the presidency and was published in month 17 — an extraordinarily fast turnaround for a project of this scope. The misconception, she says, is that people imagine a hotline rings and material goes straight into a file for later publication. For this book, every piece of reporting required months of confirmation. She says she knows there's a misconception about how this works, and gently but firmly pushes back on it.
-
Miller closes the Haberman segment on a lighter note, asking whether she dreams about the people she covers. Haberman's deadpan response: she doesn't sleep enough to reach a REM cycle, let alone dream. She promises to text Miller if that changes. Miller signs off warmly, holding up the book's gold cover on camera, and they agree to speak again soon.
-
Between the Haberman and Kasky segments, OnDeck runs a second sponsorship read promoting its small business loans up to $400,000, A+ BBB rating, and Trustpilot reviews, with an invitation to apply at ondeck.com. Standard interstitial with no new editorial content.
-
Tim Miller introduces Cameron Kasky — former Parkland activist, congressional candidate, and Ro Khanna advisor — and immediately digs into the previous night's Colorado primary results. Michael Bennet lost the governor's race, Phil Weiser (attorney general) lost to a more progressive challenger, and Hickenlooper survived a Senate challenge but not without a significant protest vote. The most striking result: DSA-affiliated Milot Quiros defeated Diana DeGette, who had represented Denver in Congress since Miller was a child. Kasky notes that critics immediately said after the New York DSA wave that it was a local phenomenon. Colorado just proved them wrong. He also flags that another candidate — Manny, in Colorado's 8th district — won and happens to be notably handsome, briefly derailing the conversation.
-
Miller frames the Gaza question as 'table stakes' in progressive primaries — the minimum requirement to get in the door with progressive voters, after which other factors determine the outcome. Kasky agrees but adds texture: the Israel issue became a credibility problem specifically for Dan Goldman, whose ideological Zionism was genuine and visible, making his position politically untenable in NY-10. Espaillat's case was different — Kasky believes he probably could have survived had he adjusted his position, because unlike Goldman, there was no personal or religious tie to Zionism for Espaillat, just political habit. Kasky also notes that AIPAC's brand has become so toxic that even fundamentally pro-Israel Democratic candidates in NY-12 — including Alex Borres and Michael Lasher — were telling AIPAC explicitly not to donate to them. The discussion ranges across Daria Leza's upset of Espaillat in Harlem and the Brad Lander-Dan Goldman Brooklyn dynamic.
-
Miller plays a viral clip of Scott Wiener being confronted on the streets of San Francisco by protesters declaring he 'stopped being queer the moment he supported Israel.' Miller objects on multiple grounds: the tactic is counterproductive with a politician who has actually moved on the issue, the notion of 'de-queering' someone over foreign policy is absurd, and at least one of the protesters appears to be a straight man rather than a member of the LGBTQ community. Kasky can't speak to the specific individuals involved but raises a broader concern: a significant portion of the anti-Zionist activist space, in his experience, talks far more about hating Israel and the Zionist apparatus than about the actual welfare of Palestinians being killed. The bird-doggers confronting Wiener, he suggests, were driven by anger toward him rather than genuine concern for people on the ground.
-
Miller asks Kasky to go deeper on his travels with progressive Senate candidates Graham Plattner in Maine and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan. Kasky's Maine dispatch is vivid: he arrived the day after a major New York Times scandal story dropped on Plattner, without his anxiety medication, expecting chaos. Instead he found hundreds of Mainers in an upbeat mood. The explanation, a local offered: in a state with one or two degrees of separation between everyone, the 'revelations' were things people already knew. In Michigan, El-Sayed's campaign has evolved from combative messaging to something more aspirational — a crescendo of positivity that Kasky finds interesting to observe. Miller notes Plattner is down 3 points to Susan Collins in polling and invokes his own Tea Party experience: the trick is channeling primary-base energy outward toward Collins, not inward toward ideological purity fights.
-
The episode winds down with Miller warmly thanking Kasky for visiting him in New Orleans, where they apparently enjoyed Guy's Po' Boy and Popeyes. Kasky raves about the city's food, noting that even the convenient mid-tier meals were exceptional. Miller plugs Cameron as the podcast's ongoing correspondent for DSA, bisexuality, and 'looksmaxing,' signs off, and thanks the production team — lead producer Katie Cooper, associate producer Ansley Skipper, video editor Katie Lutz, and audio engineer Jason Brown. A brief, absurdist comedic song plays before the formal credits roll.
- CECOT
- Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo — El Salvador's maximum-security megaprison, described as a brutal facility used by the Trump administration to detain deportees, including people with no prior criminal convictions.
- Habeas corpus
- The legal right requiring that a person under arrest be brought before a judge; the episode references Trump's consideration of suspending it for undocumented migrants.
- Presidential immunity ruling
- The 2024 Supreme Court decision holding that presidents have broad immunity from criminal prosecution for official acts in office, which Trump's team used to argue sweeping legal protection.
- Iron fist
- Phrase Trump and his team use to describe how he maintains control over congressional Republicans — through a combination of awe and fear rather than policy persuasion.
- DSA
- Democratic Socialists of America — a left-wing political organization whose endorsed candidates have been winning Democratic primary races across multiple U.S. cities and states.
- EEOB (Eisenhower Executive Office Building)
- The large federal office building adjacent to the West Wing of the White House that houses many executive branch offices; Musk set up his workspace there.
- Fiat
- An authoritative decree issued without deliberation or consent; used here to describe how Musk made government-cutting decisions unilaterally.
- USAID
- U.S. Agency for International Development — a congressionally established agency that delivers foreign humanitarian aid; Musk targeted it for elimination early in Trump's second term.
- Chronic venous insufficiency
- A circulatory condition in which leg veins fail to return blood efficiently to the heart, causing swelling (as in Trump's publicly photographed ankles).
- Truth Social
- Trump's own social media platform, launched after he was banned from Twitter/X; Haberman argues it created a more insular, sycophantic information bubble than Twitter.
- Board of Regents (Smithsonian)
- The governing body of the Smithsonian Institution, chaired by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, which sets institutional policy and is being pressured by the Trump administration on art curation.
- Bird-dogging
- A political activism tactic of publicly confronting elected officials at events to demand answers or draw attention to an issue; used to describe the Scott Wiener protest in San Francisco.
- AIPAC
- American Israel Public Affairs Committee — the prominent pro-Israel lobbying organization; Cameron Kasky argues its brand has become so toxic that even pro-Israel Democratic candidates are rejecting its donations.
- Interregnum
- The period between two governments or administrations; used here to refer to the time between Trump's 2020 defeat and his 2025 return to power.
- Capricious
- Given to sudden, unpredictable changes; implicitly used to describe how random individuals (like Lindsay Halligan) can capture Trump's attention and redirect government focus.
- REM cycle
- Rapid Eye Movement sleep — the deep stage of sleep associated with dreaming; Haberman jokes she sleeps so little she never reaches it.
- Maximalist
- Pursuing goals to their furthest possible extent without compromise; used by Haberman to describe the Trump administration's approach to expanding executive power.
Chapter 3 · 02:55
Why 'Regime Change' and the Trump Transformation Thesis
Haberman pushes back on Miller's skepticism, explaining that 'Regime Change' is not nostalgic re-reporting but an attempt to understand something genuinely new. Unlike the first term — where half the White House viewed Trump as dangerous and was actively leaking — the current administration is staffed by true believers who want Trump's agenda to succeed. The book nearly killed Haberman and Swan to report, she says, because the sources are tight-knit and secrets are kept. The core thesis: Trump has expanded and transformed the U.S. presidency to a degree not seen in our lifetimes, and the title 'Regime Change' reflects the authors' belief that America is experiencing a domestic version of the phenomenon usually reserved for foreign nations.
Losing in 2020 was the best thing that ever happened to Trump's power. He avoided post-pandemic inflation and the Afghanistan withdrawal, became a martyr figure through indictments and assassination attempts, and returned to the White House with an iron grip on his party that a consecutive second term never would have produced.
Chapter 4 · 04:25
Trump's Loss in 2020 Made Him More Powerful
Haberman lays out the book's central counterintuitive premise: Trump's 2020 defeat was actually the foundation of his current power. Had he won, he would have owned post-pandemic inflation and the chaotic Afghanistan withdrawal — both deeply damaging political liabilities. Instead, he became a mythic figure within his party, enduring criminal indictments, a conviction, civil suits, and two assassination attempts. The resulting congressional Republican dynamic is one of both awe and fear, enabling Trump to maintain what he and his team openly call an 'iron fist.' His ban from Twitter, far from being a political setback, helped insulate him — his most caustic posts went to Truth Social, reaching far fewer people. The cumulative effect is a president who could never have wielded this much power with two consecutive terms.
Claims made here
Trump being banned from social media helped him politically because most people were not seeing his most caustic posts on Truth Social.
Haberman argues Trump is in a better position than he would have been with two consecutive terms — he avoided post-pandemic inflation and the Afghanistan withdrawal.
Trump planned to include a line about sweeping J6 pardons in his inaugural address. An aide warned it would cause Democrats to walk out on camera — Trump's only concession to decorum. Hours later, he pardoned roughly 1,500 people anyway, including those who attacked police.
Chapter 5 · 06:50
Presidential Immunity and the Pardon Radius
The conversation moves to one of the book's most vivid early scenes: Trump wanted to announce sweeping J6 pardons in his inaugural address. An aide warned that Democrats would walk out on camera, and Trump relented — his last concession to decorum. Hours later he pardoned roughly 1,500 people anyway, including those who attacked police officers. The immunity discussion then expands to the Supreme Court's presidential immunity ruling, which Trump has internalized as a simple, all-encompassing phrase: 'I'm immune.' Haberman reveals that Trump has repeatedly told associates he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within 200 to 250 feet of the Oval Office — what she calls a 'pardon radius.' Several people who have spoken to Haberman and Swan are personally banking on receiving one. It creates, she notes, 'a certain mindset.'
Claims made here
Trump issued roughly 1,500 grants of clemency on Inauguration Day of his second term, including pardons for Jan. 6 rioters who attacked police officers.
The Supreme Court ruled that all presidents have immunity for official acts in office, and the belief among Trump's team is that this immunity will be interpreted broadly.
Trump has repeatedly told people he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within approximately 200-250 feet of the Oval Office.
Trump issued roughly 1,500 grants of clemency on Inauguration Day, including pardons for Jan. 6 rioters who attacked police officers.
Trump has told people repeatedly he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within 200-250 feet of the Oval Office. Multiple aides are personally counting on their own pardon. It's not just bravado — it's a governing philosophy.
Trump has repeatedly told people he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within 200-250 feet of the Oval Office.
Musk rejected his cramped West Wing office and set up shop in the grand Secretary of War suites in the EEOB, playing video games late into the night and calling Trump to propose new cuts. He was essentially a co-president — Trump's own staff often found out about Musk's decisions after the fact.
Chapter 6 · 10:40
Elon Musk: The De Facto Co-President
Haberman turns to one of the most astonishing periods in the book: the Musk co-presidency. Musk rejected his cramped West Wing 'hovel' and relocated to the magnificent Secretary of War suites in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building, which he made his own with large video game screens. According to Haberman's reporting, he would call Trump late at night to propose cutting government entities — including, in one instance, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. His unilateral decisions often surprised Trump's own official staff. He didn't always align with Stephen Miller or Russell Vought on methods, creating internal friction. His most aggressive target was USAID — a congressionally established agency — which he effectively dismantled, leaving Marco Rubio to clean up the mess. The Musk era, Haberman notes, feels like ancient history now, but it dominated the first several months of the presidency and had lasting consequences.
Claims made here
Elon Musk moved into the Secretary of War suites in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building and would call Trump late at night to propose cutting government entities, including the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Elon Musk operated out of grand Secretary of War suites in the EEOB, making unilateral decisions about cutting government agencies while often leaving Trump's own staff in the dark.
Rubio sat with El Salvador's Bukele in his palace and personally hashed out the CECOT arrangement, which was supposed to target only verified gang members. The vetting proved to be fiction — innocent people, including Venezuelans with no-deportation orders, ended up in the gulag. Rubio is not the moderate anyone hoped for.
Chapter 7 · 14:30
Marco Rubio and the CECOT Deal
Tim Miller zeroes in on what he considers one of the most underreported revelations in the book: Rubio sitting with Bukele in his palace and personally hashing out the CECOT arrangement. The original pitch was a 'safe third' style agreement, but Bukele offered up CECOT as a destination for deportees — supposedly the most dangerous gang members, each rigorously vetted. The vetting, as events proved, was fiction: innocent people were sent, including Venezuelans with explicit no-deportation orders to El Salvador. One such case became a weeks-long political controversy for the administration. Haberman argues the Rubio-Bukele scene is emblematic of what this administration actually looks like — and that the desire to cast Rubio as a grown-up or a John Kelly figure is simply not supported by anything in the reporting.
Claims made here
Marco Rubio personally negotiated the CECOT deportation arrangement with El Salvador's President Bukele inside Bukele's palace, a deal that led to innocent people being sent to the foreign prison.
Rubio personally negotiated with El Salvador's Bukele in his palace to create the CECOT deportation arrangement, which ultimately sent innocent people to the foreign prison.
Chapter 8 · 18:20
Rubio Is Having the Time of His Life
Having personally observed Rubio in the White House's Upper Press area, Haberman reports that he is constantly in and out of Caroline Levitt's office and 'looks like he is having the time of his life.' This contrasts sharply with the first term's reluctant adults — John Kelly and Jim Mattis, both of whom considered Trump dangerous and found his worldview detestable. Rubio, by contrast, rarely travels internationally despite being Secretary of State because he believes he needs to be physically near Trump. And the reason for that, Haberman explains, is that the entire government is run by six to eight people depending on the issue. If you're not in the room with Trump, you have no idea what is happening at the State Department, the Pentagon, or the CIA.
Claims made here
The Trump administration's most consequential decisions are made by approximately six to eight people, leaving senior officials at the State Department, Pentagon, and CIA out of the loop.
Stop looking for a John Kelly or Jim Mattis in this White House. Rubio is constantly in the West Wing, in and out of the press secretary's office, and by Haberman's eyewitness account, loving every minute of it. He's dual-hatted as Secretary of State and National Security Advisor specifically because he wants to be near Trump — not to restrain him.
The most consequential decisions in the Trump administration are made by just six to eight people, leaving senior officials at State, the Pentagon, and CIA out of the loop.
Chapter 9 · 21:30
Bulwark Membership Pitch: Take Back July 4th
Miller delivers a characteristically spirited membership pitch, arguing that the left and center should not cede July 4th patriotism to Trump and MAGA. 'We're here, we're queer, we're Americans, we love it,' he declares, offering a full Bulwark membership for $86 a year — 14% off — for the July 4th week only at thebulwark.com/july4. A Nordstrom Rack advertisement follows, promoting up to 60% off brands like Rag & Bone, Levi's, Adidas, and Free People through the Nordy Club loyalty program.
A staffer objected to an exhibit, and Trump soon demanded the firing of the National Portrait Gallery's director and issued orders controlling what art could be shown at Smithsonian institutions. At a Board of Regents meeting with Chief Justice Roberts present, a young Vance aide pulled out an iPad and declared a trans-themed painting 'not what Americans want to see.'
Chapter 11 · 28:40
Natalie Harp: The Human Printer's Love Notes
Tim Miller pivots to a more personal revelation from the book: the notes that Natalie Harp, Trump's constant information aide and 'human printer,' was leaving in his private White House spaces. Haberman describes them as raw and emotional — in one, Harp wrote 'You are all that matters to me.' The Secret Service was alarmed enough to raise concerns. Trump is open about his feelings toward Harp: she loves him on staff, he tells people, as much as his wife and children do. While the rest of his aides will eventually go make money elsewhere, he says, she will never leave him. Haberman notes that Harp — a former OAN network figure who has been with Trump since late 2021 or 2022 — was present for every single court appearance during his 2024 Manhattan trial and was one of only a handful of people in the room during Haberman and Swan's fact-checking interview with Trump.
Claims made here
Trump aide Natalie Harp left notes in Trump's private White House spaces, including one reading 'You are all that matters to me,' which alarmed Secret Service agents.
Natalie Harp, Trump's constant information aide known as the 'human printer,' was leaving raw emotional notes in Trump's private White House spaces — one read 'You are all that matters to me.' The Secret Service was alarmed. Trump openly tells people she loves him as much as his wife and children.
Trump aide Natalie Harp left raw, emotional notes in Trump's private spaces, including one saying 'You are all that matters to me,' which alarmed Secret Service agents.
Chapter 12 · 32:00
Trump and Iran: A Gut Feeling That Backfired
Miller raises the Iran war and the surprising revelation that Trump was privately hawkish on Iran long before the conflict began. Haberman explains that Trump's view of Iran is rooted in his 1980s formative years — Jimmy Carter humiliated by the hostage crisis, Iran as the defining threat. When Netanyahu visited Mar-a-Lago after the Butler assassination attempt to make peace (Trump had been furious at Netanyahu for congratulating Biden in 2020), Trump made clear he would be far more aggressive on Iran in a second term. He was fascinated by Israel's pager attacks on Hezbollah and flush from what he saw as the clean, successful Venezuela operation — in which a foreign head of state was seized with no American casualties. He went into the Iran war expecting similar speed. His top military advisor Dan Caine warned him explicitly: munitions could be critically depleted, the Strait of Hormuz could be closed. Only JD Vance emphatically pushed back in the meetings. Trump went anyway. Now, Haberman says quietly, he wants out.
Claims made here
Trump believed the Iran war would be over in a few days, similar to the Venezuela operation in which a foreign head of state was apprehended with no American lives lost.
Trump's top military advisor Dan Caine warned him before the Iran war that munitions could be severely depleted and the Strait of Hormuz could be closed, but Trump proceeded anyway.
Trump has always been more hawkish on Iran than his own advisors, and he went into the war believing it would be over in days, the way the Venezuela operation was swift and clean. He was warned about depleted munitions and a closed Strait of Hormuz. He went anyway. Now he wants out.
Haberman reports Trump was always more aggressive on Iran than his own advisors, and told Netanyahu after the Butler shooting he would be far more aggressive in a second term.
Chapter 13 · 36:05
JD Vance's Allegation and the Sourcing Standoff
Miller presses Haberman on the vice president's extraordinary public allegation that the authors must have tape recordings from inside the Situation Room to have sourced certain scenes in the book. Haberman is diplomatically immovable: she will not discuss sourcing, period. She does note that the book's sourcing note describes both the volume of interviews — more than 1,000 — and the rigorous methodology for what goes in direct quotes versus paraphrase. Miller, noting this was 'a pretty serious accusation from the vice president,' doesn't push further. The exchange itself is revealing: it confirms that the book's Situation Room reporting hit a very sensitive nerve for the administration.
Claims made here
Haberman and Swan conducted more than 1,000 interviews while reporting 'Regime Change,' which covers the first 14 months of Trump's second term and was published in month 17.
Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan conducted more than 1,000 interviews while reporting Regime Change, published just 17 months into Trump's second term.
Chapter 15 · 37:50
Trump's Health: The Black Box Secret
Miller asks about the topic Haberman and Swan were least able to crack: Trump's physical health. She admits it freely — this was the area where their reporting most fell short, not for lack of trying. What is visible is telling enough: Trump falls asleep at public events and during his 2024 trial. His sleeping habits are strange — he was found still asleep late one morning by a trusted aide who went to the residence to check on him after he'd gone silent. He has chronic venous insufficiency causing swollen ankles, a condition that only became public when photographers noticed, and which Trump directed press secretary Caroline Levitt to address from the podium — a decision that struck many in the White House as highly unusual given his well-documented vanity. His visits to Walter Reed are increasingly frequent. And throughout, the administration has released less and less health information. Haberman's conclusion: beyond the visible facts of an 80-year-old man who 'looks 80,' she knows no more than the public does.
Claims made here
Trump has chronic venous insufficiency causing swollen ankles, a condition that only became public after photographers captured images of them, prompting Caroline Levitt to address it from the podium.
Trump's health is the most tightly guarded secret in his administration. He falls asleep at events, has chronic venous insufficiency with swollen ankles, and is taking increasingly frequent visits to Walter Reed — while his administration releases progressively less information about his condition.
Trump's administration has released less and less health information even as he makes more frequent visits to Walter Reed; his swollen ankles from venous insufficiency were only addressed after photographers noticed.
Chapter 16 · 40:35
Trump's Bedroom: Chips, Ice Cream, and Beautiful Mind Boxes
In one of the episode's most memorable passages, Haberman describes the state of Trump's private White House bedroom. When the Trumps returned, they wanted everything as they had left it — Melania hadn't arrived yet, so Trump was alone in the residence. He picked items from the center hall and distributed them between his bedroom and the Oval Office, which he was simultaneously gilding until there was 'not a square inch not covered in something gold colored.' In his own bedroom: a carpeted bathroom, ice cream cartons, potato chip bags, Starburst wrappers (not Starbucks, Haberman corrects — that was a typo in early editions). Staff monitored the silverware because pieces kept vanishing into the trash. And then there were the bankers boxes, stacked so high their removal left visible impressions in the carpet — the same 'Beautiful Mind boxes' that became central to the Mar-a-Lago documents indictment.
Trump's White House bedroom featured potato chip bags, ice cream cartons, Starburst wrappers, a carpeted bathroom, and bankers boxes stacked so high they left impressions in the carpet. Staff monitored the silverware because pieces kept disappearing into the trash. This is how the president of the United States lives.
Trump's White House bedroom contained potato chip bags, ice cream cartons, and Starburst wrappers, and staff had to monitor silverware disappearing into the trash.
Chapter 18 · 46:00
Outro: Closing the Haberman Segment
Miller closes the Haberman segment on a lighter note, asking whether she dreams about the people she covers. Haberman's deadpan response: she doesn't sleep enough to reach a REM cycle, let alone dream. She promises to text Miller if that changes. Miller signs off warmly, holding up the book's gold cover on camera, and they agree to speak again soon.
Critics said DSA electoral success was a New York City anomaly. Then a DSA barista defeated a 28-year congressional incumbent in Denver. Cameron Kasky argues this proves the movement can replicate its wins — but also that weak, autopilot incumbents deserve much of the blame for their own defeats.
Chapter 20 · 47:50
Cameron Kasky Joins: Colorado Primaries and the DSA Wave
Tim Miller introduces Cameron Kasky — former Parkland activist, congressional candidate, and Ro Khanna advisor — and immediately digs into the previous night's Colorado primary results. Michael Bennet lost the governor's race, Phil Weiser (attorney general) lost to a more progressive challenger, and Hickenlooper survived a Senate challenge but not without a significant protest vote. The most striking result: DSA-affiliated Milot Quiros defeated Diana DeGette, who had represented Denver in Congress since Miller was a child. Kasky notes that critics immediately said after the New York DSA wave that it was a local phenomenon. Colorado just proved them wrong. He also flags that another candidate — Manny, in Colorado's 8th district — won and happens to be notably handsome, briefly derailing the conversation.
DSA-affiliated Milot Quiros defeated veteran Denver congresswoman Diana DeGette, proving DSA electoral success is not limited to New York City.
Chapter 21 · 52:35
The Israel Question as Progressive Primary Table Stakes
Miller frames the Gaza question as 'table stakes' in progressive primaries — the minimum requirement to get in the door with progressive voters, after which other factors determine the outcome. Kasky agrees but adds texture: the Israel issue became a credibility problem specifically for Dan Goldman, whose ideological Zionism was genuine and visible, making his position politically untenable in NY-10. Espaillat's case was different — Kasky believes he probably could have survived had he adjusted his position, because unlike Goldman, there was no personal or religious tie to Zionism for Espaillat, just political habit. Kasky also notes that AIPAC's brand has become so toxic that even fundamentally pro-Israel Democratic candidates in NY-12 — including Alex Borres and Michael Lasher — were telling AIPAC explicitly not to donate to them. The discussion ranges across Daria Leza's upset of Espaillat in Harlem and the Brad Lander-Dan Goldman Brooklyn dynamic.
Claims made here
AIPAC's brand has become so politically toxic that even fundamentally pro-Israel Democratic candidates in New York's 12th Congressional District rejected AIPAC donations.
Gaza criticism is now the entry ticket for progressive voters to even hear your pitch — but it's just the ante. The candidates who have actually won built coalitions around energy, vision, and relentless work. The candidates who lost weren't simply pro-Israel; they were also stale, complacent, and neglecting chunks of their districts.
Cameron Kasky reported that even fundamentally pro-Israel candidates in New York's 12th district rejected AIPAC money because the organization's brand has become so toxic it could cost them their elections.
Chapter 22 · 59:00
Scott Wiener Gets De-Queered and the Movement's Self-Policing Problem
Miller plays a viral clip of Scott Wiener being confronted on the streets of San Francisco by protesters declaring he 'stopped being queer the moment he supported Israel.' Miller objects on multiple grounds: the tactic is counterproductive with a politician who has actually moved on the issue, the notion of 'de-queering' someone over foreign policy is absurd, and at least one of the protesters appears to be a straight man rather than a member of the LGBTQ community. Kasky can't speak to the specific individuals involved but raises a broader concern: a significant portion of the anti-Zionist activist space, in his experience, talks far more about hating Israel and the Zionist apparatus than about the actual welfare of Palestinians being killed. The bird-doggers confronting Wiener, he suggests, were driven by anger toward him rather than genuine concern for people on the ground.
Claims made here
Dan Goldman won the 2022 NY-10 Democratic primary with approximately 26% of the vote in a large field.
Dan Goldman won the 2022 NY-10 Democratic primary with just 26% of the vote in a crowded field, a result that left him politically vulnerable from the start.
Chapter 23 · 1:01:40
On the Ground: Maine's Plattner and Michigan's Abdul El-Sayed
Miller asks Kasky to go deeper on his travels with progressive Senate candidates Graham Plattner in Maine and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan. Kasky's Maine dispatch is vivid: he arrived the day after a major New York Times scandal story dropped on Plattner, without his anxiety medication, expecting chaos. Instead he found hundreds of Mainers in an upbeat mood. The explanation, a local offered: in a state with one or two degrees of separation between everyone, the 'revelations' were things people already knew. In Michigan, El-Sayed's campaign has evolved from combative messaging to something more aspirational — a crescendo of positivity that Kasky finds interesting to observe. Miller notes Plattner is down 3 points to Susan Collins in polling and invokes his own Tea Party experience: the trick is channeling primary-base energy outward toward Collins, not inward toward ideological purity fights.
Claims made here
A poll shows DSA-backed Maine Senate candidate Graham Plattner trailing incumbent Republican Susan Collins by 3 points.
A poll shows DSA-backed Graham Plattner trailing Susan Collins by 3 points in the Maine Senate race, testing whether primary energy can translate to a general election win.
Cameron Kasky was in Maine without his anxiety medication the day after a major New York Times scandal story dropped on Graham Plattner. He expected chaos. Instead, the energy was overwhelmingly positive — because in Maine, where everyone knows everyone, the 'revelations' were already known. A poll shows Plattner down just 3 to Collins.
No indexed bits in this chapter.
Show stoppers
Snapshots ()
Key Quotes ()
This episode
Cast
-
Central subject of Haberman and Swan's book 'Regime Change,' discussed in terms of expanded executive power, pardons, health, and personal habits.
-
Secretary of State and National Security Advisor who personally brokered the CECOT deal with Bukele and is portrayed as an enthusiastic participant in Trump's agenda, not a moderating force.
-
Track
Described as a de facto co-president in the early months of Trump's second term, operating from the EEOB Secretary of War suites and making unilateral decisions about cutting government agencies.
-
Vice President who accused Haberman of publishing classified tape recordings and was reportedly the only official to emphatically push back on Trump going to war with Iran.
-
Trump aide known as the 'human printer' who left raw emotional love notes in Trump's private White House spaces, alarming the Secret Service.
-
Co-author with Maggie Haberman of 'Regime Change: Inside the Imperial Presidency of Donald Trump.'
-
Israeli Prime Minister who visited Mar-a-Lago after the Butler shooting to reconcile with Trump, during which Trump made clear his hawkish intentions toward Iran.
-
NY-10 congressman who lost his reelection bid, partly because his strong Zionist identity made his pro-Israel stance a major political liability among progressive voters.
-
El Salvador's president, described as a notorious dictator, with whom Rubio personally negotiated the CECOT deportation arrangement.
-
Progressive Michigan Senate candidate whose campaign Cameron Kasky observed, noted for shifting from combative to aspirational messaging.
-
DSA-backed Maine Senate candidate trailing Susan Collins by 3 points in polling, whom Cameron Kasky visited on the campaign trail.
-
Veteran Denver congresswoman who lost her seat to DSA-affiliated Milot Quiros in the 2025 primary after decades in Congress.
-
Celebrated artist whose trans-themed work was targeted by a Vance aide at a Smithsonian Board of Regents meeting attended by Chief Justice Roberts.
-
Maine's incumbent Republican Senator being challenged by DSA-backed candidate Graham Plattner, ahead by 3 points in polling.
-
Cultural and research institution whose art curation and leadership are being pressured and politicized by the Trump White House.
-
Issued the presidential immunity ruling that Trump invokes to claim broad legal protection for actions taken in office.
-
Congressionally established foreign aid agency that Elon Musk targeted for elimination in the early months of Trump's second term, leaving Marco Rubio to handle the fallout.
-
Pro-Israel lobbying organization whose brand Cameron Kasky describes as so toxic that even pro-Israel Democratic candidates are rejecting its donations.
-
Book by Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan covering the first 14 months of Trump's second term, published in month 17 after an accelerated schedule.
-
El Salvador's maximum-security megaprison used by the Trump administration to detain deportees, including innocent people and those with no-deportation orders.
Stats
This episode
Claims & Sources
Factual claims made this episode, and whether a source was named.
Trump issued roughly 1,500 grants of clemency on Inauguration Day of his second term, including pardons for Jan. 6 rioters who attacked police officers.
Trump has repeatedly told people he will issue preemptive pardons to anyone who has come within approximately 200-250 feet of the Oval Office.
The Supreme Court ruled that all presidents have immunity for official acts in office, and the belief among Trump's team is that this immunity will be interpreted broadly.
Trump being banned from social media helped him politically because most people were not seeing his most caustic posts on Truth Social.
The Trump administration's most consequential decisions are made by approximately six to eight people, leaving senior officials at the State Department, Pentagon, and CIA out of the loop.
Elon Musk moved into the Secretary of War suites in the Eisenhower Executive Office Building and would call Trump late at night to propose cutting government entities, including the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
Marco Rubio personally negotiated the CECOT deportation arrangement with El Salvador's President Bukele inside Bukele's palace, a deal that led to innocent people being sent to the foreign prison.
Trump aide Natalie Harp left notes in Trump's private White House spaces, including one reading 'You are all that matters to me,' which alarmed Secret Service agents.
Trump's top military advisor Dan Caine warned him before the Iran war that munitions could be severely depleted and the Strait of Hormuz could be closed, but Trump proceeded anyway.
Haberman and Swan conducted more than 1,000 interviews while reporting 'Regime Change,' which covers the first 14 months of Trump's second term and was published in month 17.
Trump has chronic venous insufficiency causing swollen ankles, a condition that only became public after photographers captured images of them, prompting Caroline Levitt to address it from the podium.
Dan Goldman won the 2022 NY-10 Democratic primary with approximately 26% of the vote in a large field.
A poll shows DSA-backed Maine Senate candidate Graham Plattner trailing incumbent Republican Susan Collins by 3 points.
AIPAC's brand has become so politically toxic that even fundamentally pro-Israel Democratic candidates in New York's 12th Congressional District rejected AIPAC donations.
Trump believed the Iran war would be over in a few days, similar to the Venezuela operation in which a foreign head of state was apprehended with no American lives lost.