Smosh Reads Reddit Stories

Podbit · Smosh Reads Reddit Stories

Am I The Ally? | Reading Reddit Stories

Explore episode Jun 27, 2026

Where this was said

Story 5: Gay Man Forced to Take Paternity Test Despite Having a Male Fiancé

At 49:20 · chapter starts 38:35

The final Reddit story is also the wildest. The narrator is an openly gay man who has been friends with a coworker named Robert for four years. Robert has five children — four blonde boys who look just like him and a new daughter with curly red hair like her mother Danielle. The narrator, himself a redhead, jokes that 'the red is alive' upon meeting the baby. Robert never lets it go. For weeks he complains his daughter doesn't look like him, escalating to a full breakdown at work where he accuses Danielle of cheating and points directly at the narrator — openly gay, male fiancé, pride stickers all over his car — as the culprit. After the narrator tells Danielle what happened, Robert is kicked out. He then tracks down the narrator's partner Elliott and calls with threatening voicemails. The paternity test proceeds. The group notes that Robert's entire meltdown is built on not understanding how genetics work, and Jared identifies a specific form of straight-male narcissism — the belief that a gay man might be faking his orientation to covertly access a straight man's wife.

Society & Culture
Gay Man Demanded to Take Paternity Test for Coworker's Baby

Am I The Ally? | Reading Reddit Stories · Jun 27, 2026 Society & Culture

Robert, convinced his wife was cheating, pointed across the factory floor at his openly gay colleague — a man with a male fiancé and pride stickers all over his car — and demanded a paternity test. The accusation destroyed Robert's marriage, spawned threatening voicemails, and ended with a Reddit post explaining why the gay man texted the wife directly.

Society & Culture
Narcissism, Genetics, and a Paranoid Husband

Am I The Ally? | Reading Reddit Stories · Jun 27, 2026 Society & Culture

Jared Goldstein articulated something rarely named: a brand of straight male narcissism where a man convinces himself a gay person might be faking their orientation in order to covertly access his partner. It's not just ignorance — it's a collision of homophobia, sexism, and profound insecurity.

Similar podbits

Comedy
Bobby Walked 7 Miles Home With Dicks on His Face

Tortilla Face · Aug 10, 2026 Comedy

At a childhood sleepover in Sacramento, Bobby Lee's friends drew penises all over his face while he slept. He woke up, cried, and walked 7 miles down a dirt road before Eric Purvis's mom drove out to retrieve him.

Comedy
Cracking the Aladdin 9/11 Code

Tortilla Face · Aug 10, 2026 Comedy

Their producer riffs a conspiracy theory about Lindsey Graham's death in Kyiv, which somehow leads to Bobby and Andrew discovering that every lyric of 'A Whole New World' from Aladdin secretly describes 9/11. They are disturbingly convincing.

Comedy
The Caddyshack Drug Revelation and Their Dream Movie

Tortilla Face · Aug 10, 2026 Comedy

Harold Ramis told a story about Caddyshack's cast doing drugs all day and night during Florida storm delays, with half their pay going to cocaine. Bobby Lee immediately wants to make that exact movie — and offers to relapse to do it.

Comedy
The Towel Story: Rich People Have New Towels

"Robby Hoffman" · Aug 10, 2026 Comedy

Robby Hoffman had never heard of 'new towels.' A towel, in her world, was built with the house. When Sarah Silverman announced she'd bought new pool towels, it was a class-gap revelation.